Evaluation of the Complications and Outcomes of Endoscopic and Open Surgical Treatment of Piriformis Syndrome: A Systematic Review.

BACKGROUND

Piriformis syndrome (PS), also known as deep gluteal pain syndrome, is a disorder for which surgical treatment has been proven to be effective. However, there is no current consensus on the types and rates of complications after surgery. The purpose of this study was to determine the types of complications and the frequency at which they occur based on the surgical technique, as well as determine whether complete versus incomplete tenotomy affects outcomes.

METHODS

Searches using Pubmed, MEDLINE, and Google Scholar databases were done for PS surgical outcomes studies. Reporting quality was assessed through MINORs criteria. Complications were compared across studies.

RESULTS

Seventeen studies were identified with inclusion of 386 total patients (range 1 to 64). Mean MINORS reporting quality was 10.3 of 16 for noncomparative and 17.6 of 24 for comparative studies. Complications were seen in 49 of 386 cases (12.7%). The most common reported complication was lack of relief (4.9%), followed by recurrence of symptoms (2.6%), wound/infection (2.3%), hip abduction weakness (1.6%), posterior femoral cutaneous nerve injury (1%), and foreign body reaction (0.3%). Outcomes were favorable across all studies, and complication type and frequency were similar regardless of open versus endoscopic surgical approach. We found limited evidence that incomplete tenotomy is a negative predictor of improvement with piriformis surgery. No acute or delayed sciatic nerve injuries were reported.

CONCLUSION

For surgical treatment of PS, complication type and frequency are similar regardless of an open versus endoscopic approach. Incomplete tenotomy may increase the risk for lack of symptom relief.