Prediction of refraction error after toric lens implantation with biometric input data uncertainties and power labelling tolerances.

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to simulate the impact of biometric measure uncertainties, lens equivalent and toric power labelling tolerances and axis alignment errors on the refractive outcome after cataract surgery with toric lens implantation.

METHODS

In this retrospective non-randomised cross sectional Monte-Carlo simulation study we evaluated a dataset containing 7458 LenStar 900 preoperative biometric measurements. The biometric uncertainties from literature, lens power labelling according to ISO 11979, and axis alignment tolerances of a modern toric lens (Hoya Vivinex) were taken to be normally distributed and used in a Monte-Carlo simulation with 100 000 samples per eye. The target variable was the defocus equivalent (DEQ) derived using the Castrop (DEQC) and the Haigis (DEQH) formulae.

RESULTS

Mean/median / 90% quantile DEQC was 0.22/0.21/0.36 D and DEQH was 0.20/0.19/0.32 D. Ignoring the variation in lens power labelling and toric axis alignment the respective DEQC was 0.20/0.19/0.32 D and DEQH was 0.18/0.17/0.29 D. DEQC and DEQH increased with shorter eyes, steeper corneas, equivalent lens power and highly with toric lens power.

CONCLUSIONS

According to our simulation results, uncertainties in biometric measures, lens power labelling tolerances, and axis alignment errors are responsible for a significant part of the refraction prediction error after cataract surgery with toric lens implantation. Additional labelling of the exact equivalent and toric power on the lens package could be a step to improve postoperative results.