[A comparative study on the efficacy of different treatment methods for preventing vocal cord adhesion after laser treatment for glottic cancer].

Objective

Comparing the primary tumor control, vocal function recovery, postoperative adhesion rate and degree of adhesion in early glottic cancer involving the anterior commissure treated with CO₂ laser staged and lateral surgery, one-stage surgery combined with laryngeal stent placement, and simple CO₂ laser excision.

Methods

This study focuses on 83 patients with T1-2N0M0 stage glottic squamous cell carcinoma involving the anterior commissure who underwent CO₂ laser treatment. The study was divided into three groups: Group A with 15 cases, treated with staged resection surgery; Group B with 18 cases, treated with one-stage surgery combined with the placement of a silicone laryngeal stent; and Group C with 50 cases, treated with simple CO₂ laser excision. The Voice Handicap Index-10（VHI-10）, the GRBAS auditory-perceptual assessment, and the maximum phonation time（MPT） were used to evaluate the vocal function of the patients before and six months after surgery. The degree of vocal cord adhesion was assessed using the Cohen classification of vocal cord adhesion. Statistical analysis was performed to determine the differences in each indicator before and after surgery, and the primary tumor control rates among the three groups.

Results

Local recurrence occurred in 1 case each in Groups A and B, and in 4 cases in Group C, with no distant metastasis observed. Postoperative vocal cord adhesion of varying degrees occurred in a total of 77 cases, with an adhesion rate of 73.3%（11/15） in Group A, 88.9%（16/18） in Group B, and 100%（50/50） in Group C. The postoperative vocal cord adhesion rate and degree in Group C were significantly higher than in Groups A and B. The postoperative VHI-10 scores in all three groups were significantly increased compared to preoperative scores（P<0.05）, and when compared between groups postoperatively, Group C was significantly worse than Groups A and B （P<0.05）. The postoperative maximum phonation time（MPT） in Group C was significantly reduced compared to preoperative and was markedly shorter than that of Groups A and B postoperatively（P<0.05）. The postoperative grades of G（Grade） and R（roughness） in Group C were significantly higher than preoperatively, indicating a noticeable deterioration in voice quality, and were also significantly worse than those postoperatively in Groups A and B, with all differences（P<0.05）.

Conclusion

For early glottic cancer involving the anterior commissure, choosing staged surgery or one-stage surgery combined with the placement of a silicone anterior commissure laryngeal stent were better than simple laser tumor excision in terms of secondary vocal cord adhesion and voice function preservation.