Cohen's MRI scoring system has limited value in predicting return to play.

PURPOSE: Numerous authors have hypothesised that MRI scoring systems provide a valid means of predicting return to play duration following an acute hamstring muscle strain. The purpose is to prospectively investigate the predictive value of the MRI scoring system of Cohen for return to sport (RTS), following an acute hamstring injury.

METHODS

Male football (soccer) players (n = 139) with acute onset posterior thigh pain underwent standardised clinical and MRI examinations within 5 days after injury. All players underwent a standardised physiotherapy regimen with RTS documented. The MRI scoring was statistically evaluated against RTS.

RESULTS

One hundred and ten MRI-positive hamstring injuries were evaluated with RTS duration ranging from 1 to 66 days. Total Cohen's MRI score accounted for approximately 4% of the variance in RTS duration. When comparing those with an MRI score of 10 or more took on average 9.8 days longer to RTS than those with an MRI score less than 10 (effect size: 0.85, p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Utilising the Cohen's MRI scoring system previously described, we were unable to provide a clinically useful prognosis for RTS in male soccer players. This may reflect the broader challenges of attempting to accurately determine RTS duration from imaging performed at a single point in time.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Prospective case series, IV.