Comparison of "catheter" and conventional arthroscopy in the diagnosis of knee derangements.

The diagnostic efficiency of the Optical Catheter System (OCS), which uses a 1.7-mm arthroscope, was compared with that of conventional arthroscopy in 50 patients with various knee derangements in standard arthroscopic conditions. Correct diagnoses were obtained with the OCS in 98% of anterior cruciate ligament derangements--92%-98% of those involving the medial and lateral meniscus, respectively--and 96% of cartilage disorders. No false-positives were noted for anterior cruciate ligament and meniscus injuries. False-negatives were caused by abundant intraarticular bleeding (no tourniquet was applied) and peripheral meniscus tears and false-positives by synovial superposition resulting in a mistaken diagnosis of patellar chondromalacia. The OCS proved a good diagnostic tool. Its employment, especially in an outpatient setting, should be restricted to a small number of patients and entrusted to expert arthroscopists.