Titanium Cable Cerclage Increases the Load to Failure in Plate Osteosynthesis for Distal Femoral Fractures.

Background and

Objectives

The reduction of two-part oblique or spiral fractures of the distal femur using steel wire cerclage prior to plate osteosynthesis is a proven procedure. In addition to being useful in fracture reduction, wire cerclage was also shown to increase the stability of osteosynthesis. Nevertheless, metal corrosion and the allergenic potency of steel remain problematic disadvantages of this method. A biomechanical study was carried out to evaluate titanium cable cerclage as an alternative supplement for plate osteosynthesis of a distal femoral two-part fracture. Materials and

Methods

An unstable AO/OTA 32-A2.3 fracture was created in eleven pairs of nonosteoporotic human cadaver femora. All the samples were treated with polyaxial angular stable plate osteosynthesis. One femur from each pair was randomly selected for an additional fracture fixation with multifilament titanium cable cerclage. Stepwise cyclic axial loading was applied in a load-to-failure mode using a servohydraulic testing machine.

Results

All specimens (mean age: 80 years; range: 57-91 years) withstood a cycling force of at least 1800 N. With a mean load of 2982 N (95% CI: 2629-3335 N), the pressure forces resulting in osteosynthesis failure were significantly higher in specimens with an additional titanium cerclage (Group 1) than in samples that were solely treated with plate osteosynthesis (Group 2) at 2545 N (95% CI: 2257-2834 N) (p = 0.024). In both groups, cutting out the distal screws at the condyle region, resulting in shearing of the distal fragment proximal to the fracture line, was the most frequent cause of construct failure. Among the specimens assigned to Group 1, 36% exhibited a specific fracture pattern, namely, a fracture of the dorsal buttress above the cerclage. Analysis of axial stiffness (p = 0.286) and irreversible deformity of the specimens revealed no differences between the groups (p = 0.374).

Conclusion

Titanium cable cerclage application, as a supplement to an angular stable plate, resulted in an increased load to failure. In terms of stability, the use of this adjunct for fracture fixation of supracondylar two-part oblique femoral fractures might, therefore, be an option, especially in patients who are sensitive to nickel.