Effect of crown height on the screw joint stability of zirconia screw-retained crowns.

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Medium- to long-term data for the performance of zirconia crowns with titanium (Ti) bases are sparse, particularly when the crown height space and occlusal loads are high.

PURPOSE: The purpose of this in vitro study was to assess the effect of the height of zirconia screw-retained implant crowns with a Ti base on the screw joint stability after cyclic loading. A secondary aim was to investigate the survival of zirconia crowns of different heights after cyclic loading.

MATERIAL AND

METHODS

Twenty-one internal connection implants were secured between fiberglass-reinforced epoxy resin sleeves. Mandibular first molar monolithic zirconia crowns with 3 different heights (6 mm, 10 mm, and 14 mm) were milled and bonded to the Ti bases (n=7). The screws were tightened to 30 Ncm, and a 30-degree 120-N cyclic load was applied to the crowns at 2 Hz for 5 million cycles. After 5 million cycles, the crowns were evaluated for stability, and the same protocol was repeated for 275-N and 435-N loads for 5 million cycles each. After loading, the detorque values were recorded. Failure was characterized based on whether the crown, screw, and/or implant fracture was observed. The detorque values were analyzed by using a 1-way-ANOVA with the restricted maximum likelihood estimation. The percentage of torque loss was calculated. The LIFETEST procedure was used to analyze the survival probability of the groups (α=.05).

RESULTS

The effect of crown height on the detorque values of screws was not found to be statistically significant (P>.05). The mean detorque value for 6-mm crowns was 23.5 Ncm, 24.4 Ncm for 10-mm crowns, and 22.1 Ncm for 14-mm crowns. A significant effect of crown height was found on the survival (P=.006), and the time-to-failure survival of 14-mm crowns was significantly lower than the survival of 6 mm and 10 mm crowns (P=.020), where no failures were observed. Four 14-mm crowns failed between the 1 and 2 million cycles after the loads were increased to 435 N. The failure modes were the same for all the crowns, implants, and screws fractured.

CONCLUSIONS

When the tested internal connection implant was used, the crown height did not affect the detorque values, and 14-mm crowns performed similarly to the shorter crowns in terms of torque loss after cyclic loading. However, survival of the 14-mm crown-implant complex was lower, resulting in screw and implant fractures.