Whole-body cooling effectiveness of cold intravenous saline following exercise hyperthermia: a randomized trial.

INTRODUCTION

In some athletic, occupational, military and emergency settings, cold intravenous (IV) fluids are used to facilitate whole-body cooling in an effort to treat heat illness. This treatment has anecdotal support, but currently lacks evidence supporting it as a whole-body cooling modality. Other modalities may offer superior cooling rates, and thus, patient outcomes following treatment. We sought to evaluate cooling rates of cold-IV normal saline immediately following exercise-induced hyperthermia.

METHODS

Eight healthy participants (3 females; 25 ± 2y; 72.9 ± 10.9 kg) completed 2 trials in random order. Prior to exercise, participants provided a small urine sample to confirm hydration status via urine specific gravity. Wet bulb globe temperature (WBGT) was assessed throughout trials. In both trials, participants exercised outdoors until rectal temperature (Tre) reached ∼38.9 °C, or volitional exhaustion, and then were cooled. In cooling, participants received either cold-IV (∼5 °C 0.9% NaCl fluids) or no treatment (sat in the shade; passive). Throughout exercise and treatment, Tre and heart rate (HR) were monitored. During exercise and every 10 min throughout cooling, participants were asked to assess thermal sensation.

RESULTS

Hydration status (P = .847) was not significantly different prior to exercise between trials. WBGT throughout was not different between trials (P = .426). Maximum Tre reached was not different between cold-IV (38.88 ± 0.30 °C) and passive cooling (38.76 ± 0.28 °C) trials (P = .184). Mean cooling rate for cold-IV (0.039 ± 0.005 °C·min-1) was significantly greater than for passive cooling (0.028 ± 0.005 °C·min-1; P = .002). Tre throughout cooling was not different between trials (P = .707), but did decrease throughout (P = .008), regardless of trial. HR was decreased over time (P < .001), but cold-IV and passive cooling were not different throughout HR recovery (P = .141). Thermal sensation decreased throughout cooling (P < .001), but was not different between trials (p = .278).

CONCLUSION

Emergency medical personnel should adopt treatment protocols that employ documented effective treatments for exertional heat stroke. In isolation, our data casts significant doubt for the use of cold-IV saline infusion for whole-body cooling of hyperthermic individuals.