Effect of knee angle and ligament insufficiency on anterior tibial translation during quadriceps muscle contraction: a preliminary report.

Additional information is needed regarding the effects of exercise protocols on the injured or reconstructed anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The purpose of this investigation was to assess the effects of knee flexion angle and ACL insufficiency on anterior tibial translation (ATT) and patellar ligament insertion angle as subjects performed maximal isometric quadriceps muscle contractions. The subjects were two females and two males between the ages of 18 and 24 who had sustained injuries that resulted in unilateral ACL insufficiency. Each subject performed maximum isometric quadriceps muscle contractions with each leg on a Cybex II dynamometer at each of three positions: 15, 45, and 75 degrees knee flexion. A lateral knee roentgenogram was obtained as each subject maintained each isometric muscle contraction. A roentgenogram also was taken as subjects rested each knee in each of the three target positions. Anterior tibial translation for each isometric muscle contraction was assessed by measuring the anterior displacement of the tibial plateau on the isometric resisted roentgenogram relative to the resting roentgenogram. Patellar ligament insertion angle also was measured for each roentgenogram. Maximum ATT occurred at the 15 degrees knee flexion target angle for two subjects and at the 45 degrees target angle for the other two subjects. Patellar ligament insertion angle decreased as knee flexion angle increased. Appreciable stress may be imposed on the ACL as patients perform maximum quadriceps muscle contractions in positions of terminal knee extension and in midrange positions previously reported as being safe for maximal effort quadriceps exercise. Magnitude of stress imposed on the ACL is discussed as a function of the length-tension relationship of the quadriceps muscle-tendon unit and insertion angle of the patellar ligament. Suggestions are made for additional research regarding appropriate muscle strengthening protocols for patients who have undergone ACL reconstruction.