Cognitive and visual processing performance in Parkinson's disease patients with vs without visual hallucinations: A meta-analysis.

IMPORTANCE

Cognitive and visual impairments in Parkinson's Disease Psychosis (PDP) raise the question of whether a specific profile of impaired cognition and visual function is linked to vulnerability to visual hallucinations (VHs). Previous studies have limited sample sizes and only included a sub-sample of tests. This is the first meta-analysis quantifying visuo-cognitive impairments in PDP patients across a spectrum of tests and taking into account potential confounding factors such as levodopa medication, illness duration and general cognitive ability.

OBJECTIVE

Compare visual processing and cognitive performance between PD patients with and without VHs (PDVH and PDnoVH).

METHODS

Four databases (PubMed, PsychINFO, Scopus, WebOfScience) were searched for studies on visual and/or cognitive performance of PDnoVH and PDVH published up to 02/2020. For each task, means and SDs were extracted and standardized-mean-differences (SMDs) between-groups calculated. Effect-sizes (Hedges' g) were calculated for all comparisons and synthesized in random-effects meta-analyses with robust-variance-estimation (accounting for multiple correlated measures within each study per cognitive/visual domain). Publication bias was assessed with funnel plots and Egger intercept.

RESULTS

N = 99 studies including 2508 PDVH patients (mean age 68.4 years) and 5318 PDnoVH (mean age 66.4 years) were included in the seven meta-analyses. PDVH patients performed worse than PDnoVH across all measures of cognition and visual processing, with the greatest between-group effect-sizes in executive functions, attention, episodic memory and visual processing. Study characteristics were not significantly associated with between-group differences in the domains investigated. Age-differences were significantly associated with performance differences in general cognition, working memory and executive functions.

CONCLUSION

Models of PDVH need to incorporate a wider range of cognitive and processing domains than currently included. There is a need for studies disentangling the temporal relationship between cognitive/visual deficits and VHs as early identification of risk before the onset of VHs could mitigate later outcomes such as progression to dementia.