Potential use of hydroxyapatite combined with hydrated lime or zeolite to promote growth and reduce cadmium transfer in the soil-celery-human system.

Although hydroxyapatite (HAP) can prominently lower Cd uptake by celery from Cd-polluted soil, its high application rates in reality may lead to high cost and potential environmental risk. Therefore, we aimed to clarify whether combined amendments of HAP and another low-cost material (hydrated lime, corn straw-derived biochar, or zeolite) with reduced application rate of each single amendment could significantly decrease Cd transfer in soil-celery-human system without side effect on celery growth through a pot experiment. Results revealed that adding biochar, HAP, zeolite, or combined amendments had no obvious side effect on celery growth, while adding 0.3% hydrated lime significantly decreased fresh edible celery yield by 69.0%. Conversely, adding 0.5% HAP + 0.05% hydrated lime increased fresh edible celery yield by 39.8%. Additionally, adding HAP, zeolite, or hydrated lime rather than adding biochar effectively decreased total and bioaccessible Cd in edible celery. Similarly, HAP + hydrated lime and HAP + zeolite were much more efficient than HAP + biochar in lowering Cd transfer in soil-celery-human system. The total and bioaccessible Cd in edible celery were even reduced by over 50.0% after adding HAP + hydrated lime or HAP + zeolite at low rates. Considering the effects on celery growth and Cd transfer, HAP + hydrated lime and HAP + zeolite have the potential in remediating soil Cd contamination.