Completion lobectomy following segmentectomy for malignant lung tumors: a multi-institutional study of surgical feasibility, oncologic outcomes, and diagnostic challenges (ESSG-02 study).

BACKGROUND

Completion lobectomy (CL) is occasionally required after segmentectomy for malignant lung tumors, particularly in cases of local recurrence at the resection margins. However, evidence of its technical feasibility and long-term outcomes remains limited. This study aimed to evaluate the surgical feasibility and oncologic outcomes of CL following segmentectomy for malignant lung tumors in a multi-institutional cohort.

METHODS

This multi-institutional retrospective study included 18 patients who underwent CL after segmentectomy for malignant lung tumors between 2000 and 2023. The surgical procedures, perioperative outcomes, and long-term survival were evaluated. An exploratory post-hoc analysis was also performed to compare clinical and radiological features of true local recurrence and granuloma.

RESULTS

The most common indication for CL, based on preoperative clinical diagnosis, was local recurrence at the segmental resection margin (72.2%). Video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) was performed in 27.8% of patients, with no conversions to thoracotomy. Pulmonary artery (PA) injury occurred in 11.1% and postoperative complications in 27.8%, with prolonged air leak being the most common. Perioperative mortality was not observed. On final pathological diagnosis, 50.0% of patients had local recurrence, 27.8% had metachronous primary lung cancer, and 22.2% had granuloma. Among 13 patients clinically diagnosed with local recurrence preoperatively, 3 were ultimately diagnosed with granuloma. The 5-year overall survival (OS) rate after CL for local recurrence was 58.3%, with a median OS of 87.2 months. An exploratory analysis suggested that features such as interval tumor shrinkage and absence of vascular/bronchial involvement may aid in distinguishing recurrence from granuloma.

CONCLUSIONS

CL after segmentectomy is a feasible and safe procedure when performed with careful planning and may provide encouraging long-term outcomes. Preoperative differentiation between local recurrence and granuloma remains a challenge and requires thorough imaging and tissue confirmation.