Intervention for fetal obstructive uropathy: has it been effective?

The best management of fetal hydronephrosis is controversial. Despite the lack of experimental evidence that prenatal drainage of the obstructed urinary tract substantially improves ultimate renal function, various forms of percutaneous intervention on the fetal bladder and kidney have been used. To evaluate the efficacy of intervention for suspected fetal obstructive uropathy, all published reports of drainage of the fetal urinary tract up to December, 1985, were reviewed. In the 57 reported cases, the most common type of intervention was placement of a vesicoamniotic shunt (37%). Complications occurred in 25 cases (44%), including inadequate shunt drainage or migration (19%), onset of premature labour within 48 h (12%), urinary ascites (7%), and chorioamnionitis (5%). Of 28 fetuses with associated oligohydramnios, only 6 (21%) survived. 2 of these survivors had vesicoamniotic shunts, 2 single or multiple bladder aspirations, 1 an external renal drainage catheter, and 1 in-utero vesicostomy. Because of the high complication rate and lack of evidence of improved survival from in-utero drainage procedures, a prospective, randomised trial is needed to compare survival with and without vesicoamniotic shunt placement.