Conservative management of well-differentiated thyroid cancer.

BACKGROUND

Controversy exists over the optimal surgical treatment of well-differentiated thyroid cancer. Conservative surgical management reduces the risk of complications and maintains an overall survival rate equivalent to the more extensive approach.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective review of all patients with well-differentiated thyroid cancer greater than 1 cm (180 patients) who underwent surgery between 1982 and 2002 by a single general surgeon at our institution. The prevailing philosophy was to be as conservative as possible, and the predominant resection was lobectomy and isthmusectomy on the affected side.

RESULTS

In total, 90% of patients were in a definable low-risk group: 75% had conservative surgery with 4 recurrences and no mortality, 25% had extensive surgery with 3 recurrences and no mortality. The other 10% were in a definable high-risk group: 90% had extensive surgery with 9 recurrences and 4 deaths. Overall, there were 22 sites of recurrence in 16 patients. There was no recurrence in the residual thyroid tissue, with a median follow-up of 10 years. Three recurrences occurred in the resected thyroid bed; each of these patients had undergone extensive surgery. Twelve recurrences were in lymph nodes; 67% of these patients had extensive surgery. All except 1 of 7 distant metastases occurred in the high-risk group, despite the patient having undergone extensive local surgery. Recurrence did not affect survival in the low-risk group. The extensive surgery group had a 3.4% incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve injury and a 1.1% incidence of permanent hypocalcemia, with none in the conservative surgery group.

CONCLUSION

Conservative surgery for low-risk patients with well-differentiated thyroid cancer appears to be sufficient and avoids complications without significantly increased risk for local, regional or distant recurrence.