Accuracy and 'range of uncertainty' of oscillometric blood pressure monitors around the upper arm and the wrist.

BACKGROUND

Although they have been marketed widely, few data about the diagnostic accuracy of blood pressure monitors are available.

METHODS

Repeated measurements of blood pressures in 85 patients were performed in random sequence with two oscillometric blood pressure monitors around the upper arm (Visomat OZ2) and the wrist (Omron R3( and with a standard sphygmomanometer. The oscillometric blood pressure monitors were validated according to protocols of the British Hypertension Society (BHS) and the American Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI). Subsequently, sensitivity and specificity of these monitors for the diagnosis of hypertension or exclusion of the possibility of its presence in a general medical outpatient population were calculated.

RESULTS

Sphygmomanometric readings exceeded oscillometric blood pressure measurements by 3.7+/-7.5/4.8+/-5.6 mmHg (systolic/diastolic) for the upper arm and 5.7+/-6.2/6.8+/-6.8 mmHg for the wrist. Deviations occurred in both directions and were higher for blood pressures in the hypertensive range. Oscillometric blood pressure measurements at the upper arm, but not at the wrist, satisfied validation criteria of BHS and AAMI protocols. Optimal sensitivity and specificity for the diagnosis of hypertension, defined as blood pressure > 140/90 mmHg with a standard sphygmomanometer, was achieved with blood pressure limits of 133/82 mmHg for the Visomat OZ and 131/80 mmHg for the Omron R3.

CONCLUSIONS

Average sphygmomanometer values exceed oscillometrically measured blood pressure values but individual disagreements cannot be predicted. Measurements at the upper arm are more accurate than are those at the wrist according to the validation protocols of the BHS and AAMI. Additional appraisal of sensitivities and specificities and of a 'range of uncertainty' for the diagnosis of hypertension may allow better judgement of accuracy of individual oscillometric blood pressure measurements.