Analyzing the active sites of carbocatalyst for peroxydisulfate activation: Specific surface area or electrochemical surface area?

Persulfates activation by various nanomaterials has been intensively reported for advanced oxidation processes (AOPs), and substantial progress has been made in understanding the mechanism. However, most of the published articles only present the unnormalized catalytic properties, which generated confusion to compare different catalysts and identify the active sites. Herein, we presented electrochemical surface area (ECSA) as a practical normalized method and confirmed the primary active sites in N-doped graphene. By controlling the aggregation state of graphene sheets to adjust the activity of doped graphite-N species, the active sites for peroxydisulfate (PDS) activation were accurately estimated. In further experiments, specific surface area (SSA, by N2-physisorption and methylene blue adsorption) and ECSA were adopted to conclude the normalized oxidation rate constant and graphitic-N was confirmed as the primary site in nitrogen-doped graphene for the carbocatalyst/PDS system. The normalized results revealed that SSA derived from inert gas on materials could not reflect the true active sites at solid-liquid interface, while ECSA considering the operated solid-liquid situation can be used for accurate estimation of the active sites. Therefore, this study suggests that ECSA integrates the properties of both kinetics and thermodynamics, which can be adopted as a useful methodology for analyzing nano-sized environmental catalysts performance.