Introduction
In Japan, society is aging at an unprecedented rate, substantially changing the social system and disease distribution. Nationwide and community-wide efforts have been made toward ensuring healthy longevity, and paradigm shifts have occurred at various levels. Accordingly, frailty has received attention in preventive medicine practice. The average life span in Japan was reported as 80.98 years in men and 87.14 years in women (Japanese Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, 2018). These values continue to increase. The difference between an average life span and healthy life expectancy, namely, the point at which routine daily life becomes limited, is reportedly 8.84 years in men and 12.35 years in women in Japan. These values have remained largely unchanged for a decade. Prevention and treatment of frailty to extend a healthy life expectancy prior to the need for nursing care is a huge challenge in developed societies. In herbal medicine practice, including Kampo medicine in Japan, “Mibyo,” a presymptomatic state, has long been recognized as similarly to frailty. Use of Kampo medicine, especially Ninjin'yoeito (Ren Shen Yang Ying Tang), has been considered for frailty conditions.
Diagnosis and Pathologies of Frailty
At around 60 years old, we may experience rapid loss of muscle mass and a relative increase in fat mass associated with aging, leading to atrophy of the skeletal muscles (sarcopenia) ( 1 – 3 ). These conditions increase the risk of falls and fractures, requiring long-term care.
The Japan Geriatrics Society defined frailty as a state of increased vulnerability in elderly people before the need for long-term care (2014, Figure 1Aa ). On the other hand, the Society on Cachexia and Wasting Disorders lists disease progression as one of the diagnostic criteria for frailty (Figure 1Ab ), indicating that frailty is more consistent with a syndrome encompassing a variety of physical and mental pathologies, with an emphasis on motor function. The prevalence of frailty is estimated to be about 30% in persons over the age of 80 ( 2 ). Frailty can be observed in both malnutrition and overnutrition states and can develop into a vicious cycle known as frailty cycle/cascade, leading to a need for long-term care [( 2 , 3 ); Figure 1B ]. Physical impairment leads to psychological vulnerability, with depression and cognitive impairment, and vice versa. Depression worsens sarcopenia through excessive secretion of adrenal cortical hormones and/or reduction in physical activity ( 6 – 8 ). Locomotive syndrome is defined as age-related muscle weakness (sarcopenia) and deterioration of motor function due to articular/spinal disease or osteoporosis ( 4 , 9 ). Although frailty is a psychosomatic pathology and can be divided into physical, social, and cognitive/psychological frailty, locomotive syndrome can be viewed as a clinical condition similarly to physical frailty, with an emphasis on locomotive organs.
Sarcopenia is associated with age-related hormonal changes (decreased growth hormone/insulin-like growth factor [GH/IGF-1] and testosterone) and reduced activity (due to a sedentary lifestyle or osteoarthritis). Cachexia is based on sarcopenia and associated with a variety of diseases that may underlie frailty. Proinflammatory cytokines, including tumor necrosis factor-α, are important in cachexia ( 10 , 11 ), and may activate the ubiquitin-proteasome system to promote protein catabolism. In contrast, anti-inflammatory cytokines or IGF-1 promote synthesis of muscle proteins or regeneration of muscle fibers. The corticotropin-releasing factor/glucocorticoid system activated by stress or proinflammatory cytokines are other catabolic pathways involving the gut-brain axis [( 11 ); Figure 2A ].
Frailty and Kampo Medicine – With a Focus on Ninjin'yoeito
In the search of PubMed electronic database using the key words: “Ninjin youeito” and “human” or “Ninjin'youeito.” Eighteen and eleven literatures were identified, respectively. We excluded literatures written in Japanese, reviews, animal experiments, and in vitro experiments using human cells from the identified literatures. Seven literatures were extracted (Table 1 ) ( 12 – 25 ).
Table 1
Clinical studies of Ninjin'yoeito.
KCL, Kihon Checklist; CAT, COPD Assessment Test (CAT); HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; ADAS, Alzheimer's Disease Assessment Scale-cognitive component-Japanese version; NIDS, Neuropsychiatric Inventory depression scores; ( 12 ) * , Prescription is different from that of Japanese (Rehmanniae Radix → Rehmanniae Preparatum Radix, Adding Zizyphi Fructus and Zingiberis Rhizoma); ( 13 ) ** , Prescription is different from that of Japanese(Rehmanniae Radix → Rehmanniae Preparatum Radix, Cinnamon Bark → Cinnamon) .
| Citation | Participants | Symptom | Study design | Intervention length and measures taken | Results |
| Hsiao et al. ( 12 )* | Treatment group: | Chronic kidney | Open-label trial | 6 months | |
| n = 27, 58.4 ± 13.2 y | Disease | Serum hematocrit and albumin | No change of hematocrit, | ||
| Control group: | Increase in albumin | ||||
| n = 37, 63.8 ± 14.6 y | Blood inflammatory markers | No change in CRP | |||
| (CRP, IL-6, and TNF-α) | Decrease in IL-6 and TNF-α | ||||
| QOL | Improvement in QOL | ||||
| Xu et al. ( 13 )** | 60 (41–81) y: n = 33 | Non-anemia-related | Open-label trial | 6 weeks | |
| Fatigue with cancer | Patient-reported fatigue rating | Decrease in fatigue severity | |||
| Sato et al. ( 14 ) | n = 5 | Healthy | Open-label trial | Single dosage | |
| Plasma CGRP (calcitonin | Increase in CGRP-IS and | ||||
| peptide)-like immunoreactive | sucstance P-IS | ||||
| gene-related substances (IS) | |||||
| and substance P-IS | |||||
| Naito et al. ( 15 ) | n = 5 | Healthy | Cross-over | Single dosage | |
| Plasma motilin, | Increase in motilin, | ||||
| vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), | gastrin, and somatostatin | ||||
| gastrin, and somatostatin | No change in VIP | ||||
| Cyong et al. ( 16 ) | n = 34 | Hepatitis C virus | Open-label trial | 6 months Serum HCV-RNA | Decrease in HCV (8/34) |
| n = 37 | Hepatitis C virus | Open-label trial | 3.8 years (7 month- 7 years) | ||
| Viral titer | Viral seroconversion (8/37) | ||||
| Ito et al. ( 17 ) | Lenalidomide with NYT: | Fatigue retrospective study | 6 months | ||
| 72 (53–85) y, n = 13 | Multiple myeloma | Fatigue grade | Improvement (12/13) and | ||
| no improvement (1/13) with NYT | |||||
| Lenalidomide: | Improvement (11/23) and | ||||
| 67 (45–79) y, n = 23 | no improvement (12/23) without NYT | ||||
| Kudoh et al. ( 18 ) | Donepezil with NYT: | Aizheimer's disease | Non-randomized | 2 years | |
| n = 12, 74.5 ± 5.4 y | (mild-to-moderate probable) | open-label trial | Mini-mental state ADAS and NIDS, | No change in MMS | |
| Control group: | Improvement of ADAS and | ||||
| n = 11, 74.9 ± 3.6 y | NIDS |
In elderly individuals, polypharmacy is often problematic and may lead to adverse drug reactions (ADRs). Frailty is likely to involve multiple organ systems and may be a good target for multicomponent herbal medicine. Hozai comprises a group of Kampo formulations that restore vitality to patients who have lost psychological and physical energy due to various diseases including cancer. Hozai formulations include Juzentaihoto, Hochuekkito, and Ninjin'yoeito. Kampo theory may regard frailty as Jinkyo, which means dysfunction of Jin, and is associated with production of Ki. Ki is universal energy and a basic element of life in Kampo theory. Rehmannia root, a component of Ninjin'yoeito, is often used to treat Jinkyo, which is related to frailty, and is contained in Juzentaihoto and Ninjin'yoeito, but not in Hochuekkito. Citrus unshiu peel is contained in Hochuekkito and Ninjin'yoeito, but not in Juzentaihoto. Polygala root and Schisandra fruit are only contained in Ninjin'yoeito. In cancer palliative medicine, Juzentaihoto or Hochuekkito tend to be prescribed initially, and in serious cases are replaced with Ninjin'yoeito.
Among other crude drugs, ginseng has been used since ancient times. Panax ginseng was historically thought to promote immortality, which was sought by the first Qin Emperor. It was imported to Japan in the eighth century, in the era of Emperor Shomu, and has become one of the main components in Ninjin'yoeito. Ninjin'yoeito was frequently used for serious diseases in the Edo Period. The Heji Jufang , compiled during the Song Dynasty, states that Ninjin'yoeito is indicated for weakness due to overwork or illness, dullness of the extremities, sharp musculoskeletal pain, shortness of breath, intense low back pain, emptiness and anxiety, thirst and dry mouth, depressive mood, and lethargy, leading to a condition that is difficult to treat. It is also indicated for lung and large intestine symptoms, including cough, sputum production, diarrhea, and vomiting.
In the Journal of Kampo to Kanyaku , Domei Yakazu, who was committed to the restoration of Kampo Medicine in the twentieth century, during the Showa period, stated that Ninjin'yoeito can be used for cachexia of cancer, suggesting that it is the most powerful Hozai ( 3 ). Ninjin'yoeito is now widely used in the field of palliative medicine, including cancer treatment ( 3 , 26 , 27 ). Ninjin'yoeito increases the rate of remission in advanced gynecological cancer, as assessed by positron emission tomography-computed tomography ( 26 ). Ninjin'yoeito is used to prevent toxicity (such as impaired hematopoiesis) associated with anticancer drugs or radiotherapy, and can improve appetite, fatigue, general health status, and even survival. Ninjin'yoeito enhances the therapeutic efficacy of melphalan in multiple myeloma and reduces general malaise ( 27 ). Ninjin'yoeito also treats decreased appetite and fatigue in Sjögren's syndrome ( 28 ). Many reports on the clinical benefits of Ninjin'yoeito describe improvement of general health status in elderly ( 29 ) or postoperative patients ( 30 ), amelioration of disordered protein synthesis in hepatic cirrhosis ( 31 ) or of diabetic complications such as neuropathy ( 32 ), and recovery from anemia ( 33 , 34 ) or thrombocytopenia ( 31 , 35 ). In chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), a major underlying cauthese of cachexia, Ninjin'yoeito treats appetite loss, weight loss, and respiratory symptoms, and improves nutritional status and immune function ( 36 ). Ninjin'yoeito, but no other Hozai such as Juzentaihoto and Hochuekkito, treated cough, sputum production, and insomnia. Ninjin'yoeito is effective in control of infection after knee joint replacement ( 37 ), and increases bone mineral density in postmenopausal women, treats anosmia resistant to glucocorticoid treatment, and is effective in male infertility. Ninjin'yoeito improves cognitive function and depression in patients with Alzheimer's disease when added to treatment with donepezil ( 18 ). There are also many reports suggesting its potential usefulness in home health care and frailty ( 3 ).
Effects of Ninjin'yoeito and Mechanism of Action
Ninjin'yoeito is composed of 12 crude drugs: peony root, Japanese angelica root, C. unshiu peel, Astragalus root, cinnamon bark, ginseng, Atractylodes rhizome, Glycyrrhiza, Rehmannia root, Schisandra fruit, Poria sclerotium, and Polygala root. The main components of this formulation include glycyrrhizic acid, derived from Glycyrrhiza; paeoniflorin from peony root; ginsenosides from ginseng; hesperidin from C. unshiu peel; atractylenolide III from Atractylodes rhizome; isoastragaloside (HQ1/2) from Astragalus root; tenuigenin from Polygala; and schizandrin from Schisandra fruit (Table 2 ) ( 38 – 58 ). Glycyrrhizic acid has anti-inflammatory effect and has been clinically applied in treatment of chronic hepatic diseases. Paeoniflorin is known to suppress intracellular Ca 2+ influx and relieves muscle pain. In tumor-bearing animal models treated with anticancer drugs, Ninjin'yoeito not only improves food intake and sarcopenia, but also prolongs survival ( 59 , 60 ). Ninjin'yoeito may improve the signs of aging and significantly extend survival time in approximately 30% of Klotho-deficient senescence-accelerated mice ( 59 , 60 ).
Table 2
Effective components and indications of crude herbs in Ninjin'yoeito.
| Crude herb | Effective component | Indication of crude herb |
| Ginseng | Ginsenosides Rb1, Rg1, Re, Rf, Rd, Rc | Immune enhancement, anti-inflammation effects, antioxidant effects, memory enhancement, platelet-aggregation inhibitory effects, improvement of menopausal disorders, and induction of metabolic energy ( 38 ) |
| Glycyrrhiza | Glycyrrhizin, Liquiritin, Isoliquiritin, | Anti-inflammatory, anti-cancer and immunomodulatory effects ( 39 ) |
| Atractylodes rhizome | Atractylon, Atractylenolide I, II, III, 3β-acetoxyatractylon, 3β-hydroxyatractylon, Diacetylatractylodiol | Anti-inflammatory and antinociceptive effects ( 40 ) |
| Japanese angelica root | Ligustilide, Butylidenephthalide, Butylphthalide, | Anti-inflammatory effects ( 41 ) |
| Poria sclerotium | Pachymic acid, Tumulosic acid, Eburicoic acid | Anti-inflammatory anti-apoptotic, and anti-immunologic rejection effects ( 42 ) |
| Cinnamon bark | Cinnamic aldehyde, Cinnamyl acetate, Phenylpropyl acetate, Gallic acid | Antidiabetic effects ( 43 ), Antihyperglycemic and antihyperlipidemic Action ( 44 ) |
| Polygala root | Onjisaponin A, B, E, F, G Tenuifolioside A, B, C, D, E | Antioxidation, anti-inflammation, antidementia, and anti-aging ( 45 , 46 ) |
| Citrus unshiu peel | Limonene, Linalool, Terpineol, Hesperidin, Naringin, Poncirin, Nobiletin (-)-synephrine | Antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, antibacterial properties, and anti-cancer activity ( 47 ), anti-obesity and lipid-improving effects ( 48 ) |
| Astragalus root | Formononetin, Isomucronulatol, Calycosin, Astragaloside I-Vii, Astragaloside VIII, Astragaloside IV | Anti-aging effect, anti-tumor effects, oxidative stress reduction, immunomodulatory effects, hypolipidemic, antihyperglycemic effects, increase telomerase activity ( 49 ) |
| Schisandra fruit | Citral, β-chamigrenal, Citric acid, Malic acid, Tartaric acid, Schizandrin | Anti-aging effect, memory enhancement, enhances myogenic differentiation and inhibiting atrophy, ( 50 – 52 ) |
| Peony Root | Paeoniflorin, Albiflorin, Oxypaeoniflorin, Benzoylpaeoniflorin, Paeoniflorigenone, Paeonol Phenol β-amyrin | Anti-Inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects ( 53 ), stimulate blood circulation and exhibit anti-inflammatory, antiplatelet, and vasodilator activities ( 54 ) |
| Rehmannia Root | Catalpol, Aucubin, Rehmannioside A, B, C, D, Rehmaionoside A, B, C, Acteoside, | Hypoglycemic effect ( 55 ), diuretic effect ( 55 ), blood coagulation inhibiting effect ( 56 , 57 ), immunosuppressive effect ( 58 ) |
Ginseng, a component of Ninjin'yoeito, shows antifatigue and antidepressant effects in a forced swim test ( 61 ). Ginseng may decrease the signs of aging in a senescence-accelerated mouse (SAMP8) ( 3 ). Ginsenosides, active compounds from ginseng, are reported to have a wide variety of effects. Ginsenosides ameliorate memory disturbance induced by amyloid beta ( 62 ). In a vascular dementia model (middle cerebral artery ischemia/reperfusion), ginsenoside Rg2 improves hemiplegia and memory impairment ( 63 ). These results suggest that ginseng has neuroprotective effects. Ginsenoside Rb2 inhibits the decrease in bone mineral density in the femur and 4th lumbar vertebra in ovariectomized mice through the suppression of oxidative stress and osteoclastic cytokines ( 64 ). Ginsenoside Rd ameliorates arteriosclerosis and reduces atherosclerotic plaques through inhibition of voltage-independent Ca channels in Apo-E-deficient mice fed a high-fat diet ( 65 ). Protopanaxatriol, a metabolite of ginsenoside Rg2, improves insulin resistance ( 66 ). Ginsenoside Rg3 suppresses testosterone-induced prostatic hypertrophy and growth of prostate cancer cells through inhibition of mitogen-activated protein kinase signaling ( 67 ).
C. unshiu peel inhibits amyloid beta-induced neurite atrophy and apoptosis of neural cells. Its components, including hesperidin and narirutin, have been reported to improve cognitive function by promoting reformation of the myelin sheath that is lost during aging ( 18 ). Hesperidin treats appetite loss and sarcopenia via suppression of the serotonin pathway and recovery of ghrelin secretion in the stomach [Figure 2A ; ( 68 )]. The improvement of sarcopenia by ghrelin can be attributed to the activation of the GH/ IGF-1 system ( 69 ).
Atractylodes rhizome inhibits cell death by improving mitochondrial activity and intracellular ATP production ( 70 , 71 ). This protective effect could be important since oxidative stress is considered basic to the pathophysiology of aging ( 72 ). Atractylenolide III, a component of Atractylodes rhizome, has been reported to ameliorate depression-like symptoms and memory impairment by increasing the expression level of Ca 2+ /calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II and Creb and BDNF in the hippocampus ( 71 ).
Adiponectin has been reported to have protective effects on atherosclerosis, and mice with over-expressed adiponectin show prolonged survival, even with a high-fat and high-sucrose diet through inhibition of oxidative DNA damage ( 73 ). Astragalus root enhances insulin sensitivity via increase of adiponectin, especially its highly-potent high-molecular-weight form ( 74 ) and may prevent atherosclerosis.
Polygala root and its main component, tenuigenin, promote the growth and differentiation of hippocampal neural stem cells ( 75 ). It has been reported to improve cognitive function in adults and elderly subjects in clinical studies ( 76 , 77 ), and is approved as an over-the-counter drug.
Schisandra fruit promotes elimination of fatigue substances, such as lactate and ammonia, from the blood, and increases endurance during exercise on a treadmill via upregulation of peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ coactivator 1α, an important factor in skeletal muscle metabolism ( 78 ). Schisandra fruit increases blood estradiol, uterus estrogen receptor-α and -β, and uterine weight in an ovariectomized post-menopausal model, although it inhibits the proliferation of breast cancer cells ( 79 ). Schizandrin is a main component of Schisandra fruit.
Ninjin'yoeito is thus expected to reduce physical and psychological vulnerability related to feeding, immunity, emotion, and cognition, which are oftendisturbed in frailty patients (Figure 2B ). Ninjin'yoeito could be widely applicable in mild to severe cases of frailty ( 3 ).
Combination Therapy and Adverse Drug Reactions Due to Kampo Medicines
Kampo medicines are composed of a wide variety of crude drugs with pleiotropic effects on the psychosomatic syndrome of frailty, and Ninjin'yoeito is expected to form the basis of these medicines. Recently, Kracie Pharma Ltd. reported special drug use survey results on ADRs associated with Ninjin'yoeito Extract Granules in patients aged ≥65 years ( 80 ). The population under analysis consisted of 808 patients (210 males and 598 females, mean age of 77.8 ± 7.35 years; 538 and 262 patients with and without comorbidities; and 664 and 130 taking or not taking concomitant drugs). The incidence of ADRs was 3.09% (25 patients), and gastrointestinal disorders were most common, reported by 17 patients (2.10%). Overall, there were no significant sex-related differences, and approximately 70% of the reported ADRs occurred within 2 months of starting Kampo formulation ( 80 ). Given the low and similar incidence of ADRs associated with placebo, the medication should even be safe in the elderly.
In addition, the combined use of Ninjin'yoeito with other Kampo medicines may enhance the effects of therapy. The addition of Yokukansan and Yokukansankachimpihange treats the behavioral and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD); Rikkunshito is added for gastrointestinal symptoms, Hangekobokuto for aspiration symptoms, Hachimijiogan/Goshajinkigan for prostate symptoms, and Goshajinkigan for osteoarthritis or spondylosis in severe cases with pain or numbness ( 81 – 90 ). Although Kampo medicines are likely to cause fewer ADRs than modern medicine, multi-combination use requires caution and should be limited to 2 medicines.
Conclusions
This review describes the clinical application of Kampo medicine in frailty, with a focus on Ninjin'yoeito. As in metabolic syndrome, prevention and treatment of frailty requires diet/exercise, behavioral modification, and utilization of public healthcare resources. Given the progression to a super-aged society, paradigm shifts at both individual and societal levels are needed. The concept of “Mibyo,” a presymptomatic disease state in Kampo medicine, may be a good place to start and frailty could be an important candidate for intervention. It is important to evaluate this presymptomatic state from a scientific perspective to determine how preventive Kampo medicine should be provided. In western medicine Galen is the first to indicate the importance of diet in slowing the aging process ( 91 ), and very recently geroprotectors that delay many diseases related to aging are being considered for healthy longevity ( 92 , 93 ).
Antiaging studies have rapidly evolved, and the mechanisms behind frailty and aging have become increasingly understood. Ninjin'yoeito acts on hematopoietic stem cells to promote the growth and differentiation of erythrocytes, leukocytes, and platelets in animals and humans ( 3 , 94 , 95 ). We recently found that Polygala root, Schisandra fruit, ginseng, Rehmannia root, and C. unshiu peel, which are characteristic herbal components of Ninjin'yoeito, promote the growth and differentiation of bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells ( 66 ). The components of Ninjin'yoeito may thus be important for their effects on stem cells that may migrate and regulate brain functions associated with feeding and emotion ( 96 – 98 ). Ninjin'yoeito also increases hippocampal neural stem cells ( 75 ). These effects on tissue stem cells may underlie the pleiotropic actions on Ninjin'yoeito and suggest its use for frailty.
Author Contributions
NU wrote the manuscript. NU and AI conceived and organized the structure of the review. NR and KA contributed to the first draft. HA, YA, YS, MS, MA, and AI contributed to critical revision and approved the final manuscript for publication.
Conflict of Interest Statement
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
References
1. Morley JE von Haehling S Anker SD Vellas B . From sarcopenia to frailty: a road less traveled . J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle ( 2014 ) 5 : 5 – 8 . 10.1007/s13539-014-0132-3 24526568 PMC3953315
2. Kuzuya M Frailty: overview and association with nutrition . Jpn J Geriatr . ( 2014 ) 51 : 120 – 2 . (in Japanese). 10.3143/geriatrics.51.120 24858110
3. Inui A Frailty and Ninjin'yoeito . Phil Kampo ( 2016 ) 58 : 30 – 3 . (in Japanese).
4. Fried LP Tangen CM Walston J Newman AB Hirsch C Gottdiener J Frailty in older adults: evidence for a phenotype. Cardiovascular health study collaborative research group . J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci . ( 2001 ) 56 : M146 – 56 . 10.1093/gerona/56.3.M146 11253156
5. Sameshima N Sakaki M Ishigami M Morinaga M Amitani M Inui A Frailty and Ninjin-yoei-to . Anti. Aging. Med. ( 2017 ) 13 : 52 – 60 . (in Japanese).
6. Hubbard RE Lang I . Avoiding depression, dementia, and frailty: do you feel lucky? J Am Med Dir Assoc . ( 2015 ) 16 : 270 – 1 . 10.1016/j.jamda.2015.01.085 25717014
7. Kilavuz A Meseri R Savas S Simsek H Sahin S Bicakli DH . Association of sarcopenia with depressive symptoms and functional status among ambulatory community-dwelling elderly . Arch Gerontol Geriatr . ( 2018 ) 76 : 196 – 201 . 10.1016/j.archger.2018.03.003 29550658
8. Nipp RD Fuchs G El-Jawahri A Mario J Troschel FM Greer JA . Sarcopenia is associated with quality of life and depression in patients with advanced cancer . Oncologist ( 2018 ) 23 : 97 – 104 . 10.1634/theoncologist.2017-0255 28935775 PMC5759817
9. Yoshimura N Muraki S Oka H Mabuchi A En-Yo Y Yoshida M . Prevalence of knee osteoarthritis, lumbar spondylosis, and osteoporosis in Japanese men and women: the research on osteoarthritis/osteoporosis against disability study . J Bone Miner Metab . ( 2009 ) 27 : 620 – 8 . 10.1007/s00774-009-0080-8 19568689
10. Inui A . Cancer anorexia-cachexia syndrome: current issues in research and management . CA Cancer J Clin . ( 2002 ) 52 : 72 – 91 . 10.3322/canjclin.52.2.72 11929007
11. Amitani M Asakawa A Amitani H Inui A . Control of food intake and muscle wasting in cachexia . Int J Biochem Cell Biol . ( 2013 ) 45 : 2179 – 85 . 10.1016/j.biocel.2013.07.016 23911307
12. Hsiao PJ Lin KS Chiu CC Chen HW Huang JS Kao SY . Use of traditional Chinese medicine (Ren Shen Yang Rong Tang) against microinflammation in hemodialysis patients: an open-label trial . Complement Ther Med. ( 2015 ) 23 : 363 – 71 . 10.1016/j.ctim.2015.03.002 26051571
13. Xu Y Chen Y Li P Wang XS . Ren Shen Yangrong Tang for fatigue in cancer survivors: a phase I/II open-label study . J Altern Complement Med . ( 2015 ) 21 : 281 – 7 . 10.1089/acm.2014.0211 25918996 PMC4432886
14. Sato Y Katagiri F Inoue S Itoh H Takeyama M . Effects of Ninjin-to on levels of calcitonin gene-related peptide and substance P in humanplasma . Biol Pharm Bull . ( 2004 ) 27 : 2032 – 4 . 10.1248/bpb.27.2032 15577227
15. Naito T Itoh H Nagano T Takeyama M . Effects of Ninjin-to on levels of brain-gut peptides (motilin, vasoactive intestinal peptide, gastrin, and somatostatin) in human plasma . Biol Pharm Bull . ( 2001 ) 24 : 194 – 6 . 10.1248/bpb.24.194 11217092
16. Cyong JC Ki SM Iijima K Kobayashi T Furuya M . Clinical and pharmacological studies on liver diseases treated with Kampo herbal medicine . Am J Chin Med . ( 2000 ) 28 : 351 – 60 . 10.1142/S0192415X00000416 11154048
17. Ito T Konishi A Tsubokura Y Azuma Y Hotta M Yoshimura H . Combined use of ninjin'yoeito improves subjective fatigue caused by lenalidomide in patients with multiple myeloma: a retrospective study . Front Nutr . ( 2018 ) 5 : 72 . 10.3389/fnut.2018.00072 30186837 PMC6110850
18. Kudoh C Arita R Honda M Kishi T Komatsu Y Asou H . Effect of ninjin'yoeito, a Kampo (traditional Japanese) medicine, on cognitive impairment and depression in patients with Alzheimer's disease: 2 years of observation . Psychogeriatrics ( 2016 ) 16 : 85 – 92 . 10.1111/psyg.12125 25918972
19. Kamei T Kumano H Iwata K Nariai Y Matsumoto T . The effect of a traditional Chinese prescription for a case of lung carcinoma . J Altern Complement Med . ( 2000 ) 6 : 557 – 9 . 10.1089/acm.2000.6.557 11152062
20. Kato C Morishita Y Fukatsu T . False-positive increase in 1,5-anhydro-D-glucitol due to Kampo (Japanese herbal) medicine . Rinsho Byori . ( 1996 ) 44 : 396 – 9 . 8847825
21. Uchiyama Y Nakajima S Yoshida K Mizukawa H Haruki E . The effect of ninjinyoeito on human aorta endothelial cells . Am J Chin Med . ( 1994 ) 22 : 293 – 9 . 10.1142/S0192415X94000358 7872241
22. Uchiyama Y Nakajima S Yoshida K Mizukawa H Haruki E . The effects of ninjinyoeito on human vascular endothelial cells . Am J Chin Med . ( 1993 ) 21 : 279 – 89 . 10.1142/S0192415X93000339 8135173
23. Ogawa R Toyama S Matsumoto H . Chronic fatigue syndrome–cases in the Kanebo Memorial Hospital . Nihon Rinsho . ( 1992 ) 50 : 2648 – 52 . 1337561
24. Uchiyama Y Nakajima S Ohno T Goto M Kan M Haruki E . The effect of Ninjinyoeito on Werner's syndrome skin fibroblasts . Am J Chin Med . ( 1992 ) 20 : 295 – 305 . 10.1142/S0192415X9200031X 1471614
25. Hirai K Tanaka A Homma T Mikuni H Kawahara T Ohta S Improvement in frailty in a patient with severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease after ninjin'yoeito therapy: a case report . Front Nutr . ( 2018 ) 5 : 71 10.3389/fnut.2018.00071 30234120 PMC6131554
26. Tanaka T Antitumor effect by paclitaxel/carboplatin therapy and Ninjin'yoeito for advanced-stage gynecological cancer . Sci Kampo Med. ( 2011 ) 35 : 370 – 3 . (in Japanese).
27. Nomura S Ishii K Fujita Y Azuma Y Hotta M Yoshimura Y Immunotherapeutic effects of Ninjin-youei-to on patients with multiple myeloma . Curr Trends Immunol . ( 2014 ) 15 : 19 – 27 .
28. Katayama I Murota H Shirabe H Effect of Ninjinyoueito in improving quality-of-life measurements for patients with sjogren's syndrome with skin symptoms . Nishi Nihon Hifuka ( 2008 ) 70 : 516 – 21 . (in Japanese). 10.2336/nishinihonhifu.70.516
29. Suzuki S Aihara F Shibahara M Sakai K Special drug use surveillance for kracie Ninjin'yoeito extract fine granules -a study of safety and efficacy in elderly patients- . Jpn J Med Pharmaceut Sci. ( 2017 ) 74 : 1285 – 97 . (in Japanese).
30. Yoshikawa H Ikeuchi T Kai Y Clinical efficacy of Ninjin-Youei-To for recovery of reduced physical strength of the patients after prostate hypertrophy operation . Jpn J Oriental Med . ( 1999 ) 49 : 617 - 22 . (in Japanese).
31. Iwata K Kamimura S Shijo H Okumura M Administration of Ninjin-yoei-to to liver cirrhosis. Focusing on effects on thrombocytopia . Jpn J Clin Exp Med . ( 1995 ) 72 : 746 – 50 . (in Japanese).
32. Aiso Y Nagasaka S Tonyobyoshinkeishougai ni taisuru Ninjin-yoei-to no kouka. Shinki hihu sekigaisen taionkei ' Thermo Focus® ' ni yoru kentou . J New Rem Clin . ( 2007 ) 56 : 2028 – 32 . (in Japanese).
33. Yanagibori A Miyagi M Hori M Otaka K Matsushima H Ito M Effect of Ninjin-yoei-tou on iron-deficiency anemia . Jpn J Clin Exp Med . ( 1995 ) 72 : 2605 – 8 . (in Japanese).
34. Takemura K Erisuropoechin touyochuu no ketsuekitousekikanja no jinseihinketsu nitausuru Ninjin'yoeito no hojoteki yuukousei ni tsuite . Kampo Newest Ther . ( 2000 ) 9 : 271 – 4 . (in Japanese).
35. Kaibori M lshizaki M Matsui K A-Hon Kwon Therapeutic effects of combination therapy of traditional Japanese medicine, ninjinyoueito, and sorafenib in recipients with advanced hepoatocellular carcinoma . Jpn J Med Pharmaceut Sci. ( 2012 ) 67 : 445 – 7 . (in Japanese).
36. Kato S Tamano M Okamura A Ozone S Hoshino T Takahashi S Clinical benefits of three major Jingizai formulas in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease . Sci Kampo Med. ( 2016 ) 40 : 172 – 6 . (in Japanese).
37. Kumaki S Effects of Ninjin'yoeito after knee joint replacement . Prog Med . ( 2003 ) 23 : 2993 – 6 . (in Japanese).
38. Han SY Kim J Kim E Kim SH Seo DB Kim JH . AKT-targeted anti-inflammatory activity of Panax ginseng calyx ethanolic extract . J Ginseng Res . ( 2018 ) 42 : 496 – 503 . 10.1016/j.jgr.2017.06.003 30337810 PMC6187086
39. Yin L Guan E Zhang Y Shu Z Wang B Wu X . Chemical profile and anti-inflammatory activity of total flavonoids from glycyrrhiza uralensis fisch . Iran J Pham Res. ( 2018 ) 17 : 726 – 34 . 29881429 PMC5985189
40. Chen LG Jan YS Tsai PW Norimoto H Michihara S Murayama C . Anti-inflammatory and antinociceptive constituents of atractylodes japonica koidzumi . J Agric Food Chem . ( 2016 ) 64 : 2254 – 62 . 10.1021/acs.jafc.5b05841 26919689
41. Uto T Tung NH Taniyama R Miyanowaki T Morinaga O Shoyama Y: Anti-inflammatory activity of constituents isolated from aerial part of angelica acutiloba kitagawa Phytother Res . ( 2015 ) 29 : 1956 – 63 . 10.1002/ptr.5490 26463105
42. Wan FY Lv WS Han L: Determination and pharmacokinetic study of pachymic acid by LC-MS/MS Biol Pharm Bull . ( 2015 ) 38 : 1337 – 44 . 10.1248/bpb.b15-00121 26328488
43. Crawford P Crawford AJ . Edema from taking cinnamon for treatment of diabetes: Similar biochemistry and pathophysiology to thiazolidinedione medications . J Am Bord Fam Med. ( 2018 ) 31 : 809 – 11 . 10.3122/jabfm.2018.05.180024 30201678
44. Kim SH Choung SY . Antihyperglycemic and antihyperlipidemic action of Cinnamomi cassiae (Cinnamon bark) extract in C57BL/Ks db/db mice . Arch Pharm Res . ( 2010 ) 33 : 325 – 33 . 10.1007/s12272-010-0219-0 20195835
45. Yuan HL Li B Xu J Wang Y He Y Zheng Y . Tenuigenin protects dopaminergic neurons from inflammation-mediated damage induced by the lipopolysaccharide . CNS Neurosci Ther . ( 2012 ) 18 : 584 – 90 . 10.1111/j.1755-5949.2012.00347.x 22759267 PMC6493587
46. Zhang H Han T Zhang L Yu CH Wan DG Rahman K . Effects of tenuifolin extracted from radix polygalae on learning and memory: a behavioral and biochemical study on aged and amnesic mice . Phytomedicine ( 2008 ) 15 : 587 – 94 . 10.1016/j.phymed.2007.12.004 18289838
47. Ahn KI Choi EO Kwon DH HwangBo H Kim MY Kim HJ . Induction of apoptosis by ethanol extract of Citrus unshiu Markovich peel in human bladder cancer T24 cells through ROS-mediated inactivation of the PI3K/Akt pathway . Biosci Trends ( 2017 ) 11 : 565 – 73 . 10.5582/bst.2017.01218 29070760
48. Kang S Song S Lee J Chang H Lee S . Clinical investigations of the effect of Citrus unshiu peel pellet on obesity and lipid profile . Evid Based Complement Alter Med. ( 2018 ) 2018 : 4341961 . 10.1155/2018/4341961 30327679 PMC6169216
49. Liu P Zhao H Luo Y . Anti-aging implications of Astragalus membranaceus (Huangqi): a well-known Chinese tonic . Aging Dis . ( 2017 ) 8 : 868 – 86 . 10.14336/AD.2017.0816 29344421 PMC5758356
50. Sun J Jing S Jiang R Wang C Zhang C Chen J . Metabolomics study of the therapeutic mechanism of Schisandra chinensis lignans on aging rats induced by d-galactose . Clin Interv Aging ( 2018 ) 13 : 829 – 41 . 10.2147/CIA.S163275 29750025 PMC5935080
51. Hu D Cao Y He R Han N Liu Z Miao L . Schizandrin, an antioxidant lignan from Schisandra chinensis , ameliorates Aβ1–42-induced memory impairment in mice . Oxid Med Cell Longev . ( 2012 ) 2012 : 721721 . 10.1155/2012/721721 22829961 PMC3399599
52. Kim C Shin J Hwang S Choi Y Kim D Kim C . Schisandrae fructus enhances myogenic differentiation and inhibits atrophy through protein synthesis in human myotubes . Int J Nanomed. ( 2016 ) 11 : 2407 – 15 . 10.2147/IJN.S101299 27330287 PMC4898430
53. He D Dai S . Anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory effects of Paeonia lactiflora pall. A traditional Chinese herbal medicine . Front Pharmacol . ( 2011 ) 2 : 10 . 10.3389/fphar.2011.00010 21687505 PMC3108611
54. Bae J Kim C Kim H Park J Ahn M . Differences in the chemical profiles and biological activities of Paeonia lactiflora and Paeonia obovata . J Med Food ( 2015 ) 18 : 224 – 32 . 10.1089/jmf.2014.3144 25299493 PMC4312797
55. Kitagawa I Nishimura T Furubayashi A Yoshioka I . On the constituents of rhizome of rehmannia glutineosa LIBOSCH. forma hueichingensis HSIAO . YAKUGAKU ZASSHI ( 1971 ) 91 : 593 – 6 . 10.1248/yakushi1947.91.5_593 5105149
56. Matsuda H Fukuda S Nakanishi J Fukuda S Kubo M Inhibitory effect of oriental medicine “rehmanniae radix” on disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) . SHOYAKUGAKU ZASSHI ( 1986 ) 40 : 182 – 7 .
57. Kubo M Asano T Shimono H Matsuda H . Studies on rehmanniae radix. I. Effect of 50% ethanolic extract from steamed and dried rehmanniae radix on hemorheology in arthritic and thrombosic rats . Biol Pharmaceut Bull. ( 1994 ) 17 : 1282 – 6 . 10.1248/bpb.17.1282 7841954
58. Sasaki H Nishimura H Morota T Chin M Mitsuhashi H Komatsu Y . Immunosuppressive principles of rehmannia glutinosa var. hueichingensis . Planta Med. ( 1989 ) 55 : 458 – 62 . 10.1055/s-2006-962064 2813582
59. Chiba S Fujita H Yomoda S Effect of ninjin'yoeito on cisplatin-induced amyotropy . Kampo Med. ( 2017 ) 68 : 398 .
60. Takahashi R Chiba S Takemoto R Michihara S Han LK Hujita H Ninjin'yoeito improves survival and aging phenotype on accelerated aging model . Jpn J Psychosom Int Med . ( 2018 ) 22 : 16 – 19 . (in Japanese).
61. Hujita H Murata K Effect of ginseng on antidepressant action and fatigue Phil Kampo . ( 2017 ) 65 : 24 – 5 . (in Japanese).
62. Rokot NT Kairupan TS Cheng KC Runtuwene J Kapantow NH Amitani M . A role of ginseng and its constituents in the treatment of central nervous system disorders . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med . ( 2016 ) 2016 : 2614742 . 10.1155/2016/2614742 27630732 PMC5007341
63. Zhang G Liu A Zhou Y San X Jin T Jin Y . Panax ginseng ginsenoside-Rg2 protects memory impairment via anti-apoptosis in a rat model with vascular dementia . J Ethnopharmacol . ( 2008 ) 115 : 441 – 8 . 10.1016/j.jep.2007.10.026 18083315
64. Huang Q Gao B Jie Q We BY Fan J Zhang HY . Ginsenoside-Rb2 displays anti-osteoporosis effects through reducing oxidative damage and bone-resorbing cytokines during osteogenesis . Bone ( 2014 ) 66 : 306 – 14 . 10.1016/j.bone.2014.06.010 24933344
65. Li J Xie ZZ Tang YB Zhou JG Guan YY . Ginsenoside-Rd, a purified component from panax notoginseng saponins, prevents atherosclerosis in apoE knockout mice . Eur J Pharmacol . ( 2011 ) 652 : 104 – 10 . 10.1016/j.ejphar.2010.11.017 21122802
66. Inui A Ninjin'yoeito for frailty . In: The 22nd Annual Meeting of Japanese Society of Psychosomatic Internal Medicine . Kagoshima ( 2017 ).
67. Bae JS Park HS Park JW Li SH Chun YS . Red ginseng and 20(S)-Rg3 control testosterone-induced prostate hyperplasia by deregulating androgen receptor signaling . J Nat Med . ( 2012 ) 66 : 476 – 85 . 10.1007/s11418-011-0609-8 22101440
68. Fujitsuka N Asakawa A Morinaga A Amitani MS Amitani H Katsuura G . Increased ghrelin signaling prolongs survival in mouse models of human aging through activation of sirtuin1 . Mol Psychiatry ( 2016 ) 21 : 1613 – 23 . 10.1038/mp.2015.220 26830139 PMC5078860
69. Haruta I Fuku Y Kinoshita K Yoneda K Morinaga A Amitani M . One-year intranasal application of growth hormone releasing peptide-2 improves body weight and hypoglycemia in a severely emaciated anorexia nervosa patient . J Cachexia Sarcopenia Muscle ( 2015 ) 6 : 237 – 41 . 10.1002/jcsm.12028 26401470 PMC4575555
70. Fujita H Yomoda S Izumi H Fukunaga K Effects of Atractylodis lanceae Rhizoma on the content of ATP in the hippocampus . Phil Kampo ( 2016 ) 59 : 25 – 7 . (in Japanese).
71. Fukunaga K Izumi H Hujita H Yomoda S Mechanisms of amelioration of symptoms of Alzheimer's disease by Yokukansankachimpihange . Phil Kampo ( 2016 ) 60 : 32 – 3 . (in Japanese).
72. McHugh D Gil J . Senescence and aging: causes, consequences, and therapeutic avenues . J Cell Biol. ( 2017 ) 217 : 65 – 77 . 10.1083/jcb.201708092 29114066 PMC5748990
73. Otabe S Yuan X Fukutani T Wada N Hashinaga T Nakayama H . Overexpression of human adiponectin in transgenic mice results in suppression of fat accumulation and prevention of premature death by high-calorie diet . Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. ( 2007 ) 293 : E210 – 8 . 10.1152/ajpendo.00645.2006 17389708
74. Xu A Wang H Hoo RL Sweeney G Vanhoutte PM Wang Y . Selective elevation of adiponectin production by the natural compounds derived from a medicinal herb alleviates insulin resistance and glucose intolerance in obese mice . Endocrinology ( 2009 ) 150 : 625 – 33 . 10.1210/en.2008-0999 18927219 PMC2732290
75. Chen Y Huang X Chen W Wang N Li L . Tenuigenin promotes proliferation and differentiation of hippocampal neural stem cells . Neurochem Res . ( 2012 ) 37 : 771 – 7 . 10.1007/s11064-011-0671-3 22179853
76. Lee JY Kim KY Shin KY Won BY Jung HY Suh YH . Effects of BT-11 on memory in healthy humans . Neurosci Lett . ( 2009 ) 454 : 111 – 4 . 10.1016/j.neulet.2009.03.024 19429065
77. Shin KY Lee JY Won BY Jung HY Chang KA Koppula S . BT-11 is effective for enhancing cognitive functions in the elderly humans . Neurosci Lett . ( 2009 ) 465 : 157 – 9 . 10.1016/j.neulet.2009.08.033 19699261
78. Kim YJ Yoo SR Chae C Jung UJ Choi MS . Omija fruit extract improves endurance and energy metabolism by upregulating PGC-1α expression in the skeletal muscle of exercised rats . J Med Food ( 2014 ) 17 : 28 – 35 . 10.1089/jmf.2013.3071 24456352
79. Kim MH Choi YY Han JM Lee HS Hong SB Lee SG . Ameliorative effects of Schizandra chinensis on osteoporosis via activation of estrogen receptor (ER)-α/-β . Food Funct . ( 2014 ) 5 : 1594 – 601 . 10.1039/C4FO00133H 24881676
80. Suzuki S Aihara F Shibahara M Sakai K Special drug use surveillance for Kracie Ninjin'yoeito extract fine granules - a study of safety and efficacy in elderly patients . Jpn J Med Pharm Sci . ( 2017 ) 74 : 1285 – 97 . (in Japanese).
81. Okamoto H Iyo M Ueda K Han C Hirasaki Y Namiki T . Yokukan-san: a review of the evidence for use of this Kampo herbal formula in dementia and psychiatric conditions . Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat ( 2014 ) 10 : 1727 – 42 . 10.2147/NDT.S65257 25246794 PMC4168872
82. Saegusa Y Hattori T Nahata M Yamada C Takeda H . A new strategy using Rikkunshito to treat anorexia and gastrointestinal dysfunction . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med . ( 2015 ) 2015 : 364260 . 10.1155/2015/364260 26064162 PMC4433667
83. Iwasaki K Wang Q Nakagawa T Suzuki T Sasaki H . The traditional Chinese medicine banxia houpo tang improves swallowing reflex . Phytomedicine ( 1999 ) 6 : 103 – 6 . 10.1016/S0944-7113(99)80043-9 10374248
84. Yagi H Sato R Nishio K Arai G Soh S Okada H . Clinical efficacy and tolerability of two Japanese traditional herbal medicines, Hachimi-jio-gan and Gosha-jinki-gan, for lower urinary tract symptoms with cold sensitivity . J Tradit Complement Med . ( 2015 ) 5 : 258 – 61 . 10.1016/j.jtcme.2015.03.010 26587398 PMC4624524
85. Ishizuka O Nishizawa O Hirao Y Ohshima S . Evidence-based meta-analysis of pharmacotherapy for benign prostatic hypertrophy . Int J Urol . ( 2002 ) 9 : 607 – 12 . 10.1046/j.1442-2042.2002.00539.x 12534901
86. Hoshino N Hida K Ganeko R Sakai Y . Goshajinkigan for reducing chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy: protocol for a systematic review and meta-analysis . Int J Colorectal Dis . ( 2017 ) 32 : 737 – 40 . 10.1007/s00384-016-2727-y 27889823
87. Cascella M Muzio MR . Potential application of the Kampo medicine goshajinkigan for prevention of chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy . J Integr Med . ( 2017 ) 15 : 77 – 87 . 10.1016/S2095-4964(17)60313-3 28285612
88. Satoh H . Pharmacological characteristics of Kampo medicine as a mixture of constituents and ingredients . J Integr Med . ( 2013 ) 11 : 11 – 6 . 10.3736/jintegrmed2013003 23464641
89. Hijikata Y Miyamae Y Takatsu H Sentoh S . Two kampo medicines, jidabokuippo and hachimijiogan alleviate sprains, bruises and arthritis . Evid Based Complement Alternat Med . ( 2007 ) 4 : 463 – 7 . 10.1093/ecam/nel105 18227914 PMC2176138
90. Kimata Y Ogawa K Okamoto H Chino A Namiki T . Efficacy of Japanese traditional (Kampo) medicine for treating chemotherapy-induced peripheral neuropathy: a retrospective case series study . World J Clin Cases ( 2016 ) 4 : 310 – 7 . 10.12998/wjcc.v4.i10.310 27803912 PMC5067493
91. Burstein SM Finch CE . Longevity examined: an ancient Greek's very modern views on ageing . Nature ( 2018 ) 560 : 430 . 10.1038/d41586-018-05986-1 30127482
92. Bellantuono I . Find drugs that delay many diseases of old age . Nature ( 2018 ) 554 : 293 – 5 . 10.1038/d41586-018-01668-0 29446384
93. Fontana L Kennedy BK Longo VD Seals D Melov S . Medical research: treat ageing . Nature ( 2014 ) 511 : 405 – 7 . 10.1038/511405a 25056047
94. Miura S Kawamura I Yamada A Kawakita T Kumazawa Y Himeno K . Effect of a traditional Chinese herbal medicine ren-shen-yang-rong-tang (Japanese name: ninjin-youei-to) on hematopoietic stem cells in mice . Int J Immunopharmacol . ( 1989 ) 11 : 771 – 80 . 10.1016/0192-0561(89)90131-8 2599715
95. Zhou Y Liu J Cai S Liu D Jiang R Wang Y . Protective effects of ginsenoside Rg1 on aging Sca-1+ hematopoietic cells . Mol Med Rep. ( 2015 ) 12 : 3621 – 8 . 10.3892/mmr.2015.3884 26045300
96. Urabe H Kojima H Chan L Terashima T Ogawa N Katagi M . Haematopoietic cells produce BDNF and regulate appetite upon migration to the hypothalamus . Nat Commun . ( 2013 ) 4 : 1526 . 10.1038/ncomms2536 23443554 PMC3640364
97. Brevet M Kojima H Asakawa A Atsuchi K Ushikai M Ataka K . Chronic foot-shock stress potentiates the influx of bone marrow-derived microglia into hippocampus . J Neurosci Res . ( 2010 ) 88 : 1890 – 7 . 10.1002/jnr.22362 20155811
98. Ataka K Asakawa A Nagaishi K Kaimoto K Sawada A Hayakawa Y . Bone marrow-derived microglia infiltrate into the paraventricular nucleus of chronic psychological stress-loaded mice . PLoS ONE ( 2013 ) 8 : e81744 . 10.1371/journal.pone.0081744 24303068 PMC3841189