Introduction
Percutaneous cement augmentation is now an established mode of treatment of acute onset intractable pain due to osteoporotic vertebral fractures or chronic pain as a result of insufficient healing due to altered biomechanics or pseudoarthrosis [ 1 , 2 ]. Balloon kyphoplasty has superiority over vertebroplasty in improving the anterior vertebral height (sagittal balance) and less cement leakage [ 3 , 4 ]. Balloon kyphoplasty involves inflation of balloon in fractured vertebra to elevate vertebral end plate [ 5 , 6 ].
Symmetric and effective elevation of end plate needs two inflatable balloons to be placed through both the pedicle (transpedicular balloon kyphoplasty). Complications of balloon kyphoplasty range from mild increase in pain after procedure to cement leakage and pulmonary embolism. Cement leakage into paravertebral soft tissue occurs up to 51% in patients with no clinical significance. Paravertebral veins can lead to pulmonary embolism [ 7 - 9 ]. Epidural space cement leakage can have serious outcomes like paraplegia. Chiras et al . reported 0.4% incidence of paraplegia as a result of epidural cement leakage [ 10 ]. This leak can occur as a result of breach in medial pedicle wall or needle traversing through lamina in patients with very narrow pedicle.
Brugieres et. al . were the researchers who used the extrapedicular (transcostovertebral) approach first time for percutaneous biopsy from the central part of upper thoracic vertebrae [ 11 ]. In the subsequent years, this approach was utilized for the single balloon kyphoplasty via extrapedicular approach. Although the results of single balloon extrapedicular kyphoplasty is similar to two balloon transpedicular kyphoplasty, but it has the few advantages like short surgical time and less economic burden [ 12 ].
Standardization for single balloon extrapedicular kyphoplasty approach has not been made till now, due to variable trajectory (skin entry to centre of vertebra) at each level. So probably it could have been the reason that this approach is less practiced and need experienced hand, in comparison to two balloon transpedicular kyphoplasty [ 13 ]. This study was conducted to evaluate the functional and radiological outcome of balloon kyphoplasty and to endorse the unilateral extrapedicular kyphoplasty as practically more feasible and safer method compared to the conventional methods.
Material and Methods
A total of 81 patients were presented to our centre with osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture from February 2016 to January 2018. Among these, 59 patients (61 vertebrae) who fullfilled our inclusion criteria underwent unilateral extrapedicular balloon kyphoplasty. Inclusion criteria were single level stable wedge osteoporotic compression fractures (not improved after conservative management) with intact posterior wall of lower thoraco-lumbar vertebrae, normal neurological status and without signs of infection.
Patients of T9 or higher level of vertibra, history of coagulation disorders, pathological fracture and allergy to polymethylmethaacrylate, were excluded from the study. While 5 patients with involvement above D10, 2 patients with >2 vertebra involvements, 4 patients with posterior cortical breach and 3 patients who did not come for routine follow-up, were excluded from the study. One patient was found unfit for surgical intervention and 7 patients were not willing for any surgical procedure.
All patients underwent complete clinical, laboratory and radiological evaluation to rule out other causes of vertebral fractures like multiple myeloma, and metastasis. X-ray and CT were done for all patients to determine involved vertebral level. Pre-operatively, percentage of vertebral height loss and kyphotic angle were calculated ( Figure 1A ). Percentage height loss was calculated by comparing the anterior vertebral height of involved level with mean of anterior vertebral height of proximal and distal un-involved levels.
On Axial CT sections, distance of center of involved vertebra from skin was measured. Pain and quality of life were assessed by Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). All patients were explained in details about nature of ailment and available non-operative and operative treatment options. Detailed informed consent was taken for each case. Regarding the operative technique, under general anesthesia, the patients in prone position on a radiolucent table; C-arm was positioned in such a way that anteroposterior (AP) and lateral images were possible during the procedure and AP and lateral images were taken.
Since we were apprehensive for the epidural leakage in this technique, we preferred the general anesthesia, so that in any emergency intervention could be implemented. Following disinfection and draping, mid-line was marked after obtaining a true AP fluoroscopy image of the affected level and later, a K-wire was aligned over the skin so that it appears to bisect the affected level. A horizontal line (Line A) was drawn along the skin using this wire ( Figure 1B ).
Vertical lines were then drawn along the pedicle shadow. Pedicles were marked on the line A. Another point was marked on the line A at a distance x from midline, where x=distance of the centre of affected vertebral body from skin surface, measured on axial CT images ( Figure 1C ). This point acted as starting point and marked. Trocar and cannula were inserted from the starting point directed medially at an angle of 45° w.r.t. horizontal plane. Once the lateral wall of vertebra was reached, the needle was hammered under fluoroscopy guidance, so as to reach the center on both AP and lateral images ( Figures 2D, and 2e ). Trocar was then removed and guide wire was placed. Guide wire was then exchanged by a wider working cannula. Balloon tamp was then inserted through the cannula ( Figure 2F ) and positioned in the centere on AP and lateral images.
Dye was injected to inflate the balloon to the point where maximum fracture reduction was achieved or balloon reaches cortical wall ( Figures 3A and 3B ). polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) bone cement was then mixed. When cement reached the desired viscosity, the balloon was deflated and removed. Cement was injected slowly into the void, thus created using filler cannula under image intensifier guidance filler that was slowly pulled back as filling continued. Once filling was complete, filler was rotated approximately 360 degrees and taken out. Rotating the filler before pulling out reduced the chance of cement following the filler track ( Figures 3C, and 3D ). The procedure was aborted if there was evidence of any cement leak. Post-operative patients were allowed to walk with a supportive brace. Patients were discharged the next day with advises regarding treatment of osteoporosis.
Results
Among 59 patients, 19 (32.20%) were male and 40 (67.80%) were female, with age range of 44 to 90 years (mean 62.29±10.06 years). They all satisfied our criteria undergoing balloon kyphoplasty. Age and sex distribution was shown in Figure 4 . Totally, 28 (47.46%) patients were presented to outpatient department (OPD), and 31 (52.54%) patients were presented to the emergency room. Mean duration of presentation was 8.73 (range 2-12) days following injury. History of trivial injuries (like slip and fall) was present in 24 patients (40.68%) including fall from standing height in (18 patients, 30.51%), fall from bed (3 patients, 5.08%), sudden jerk while travelling (3 patients, 5.08%) and road traffic accidents (11 patients, 18.64%).
As depicted in Figure 5 , L1 was the most common vertebra involved (n=33, 54.10%), followed by D12 (n=15, 24.59%) vertebra. In our series, the mean segmental kyphosis correction following balloon kyphoplasty was 14.27° (SD=6.97) ranging from no change to a maximum of 30° reduction of kyphosis. Mean preoperatively segmental kyphosis was 22.81° (SD=10.93), and the mean post-balloon kyphoplasty segmental kyphosis was 8.54° (SD=11.51). At p <0.05, the result was significant with t=6.90498 and p <0.00001.
Table1
The pre-operative and post-operative values of anterior vertebral height, segmental kyphosis and VAS
| Anterior vertebral height | Segmental kyphosis | VAS | |
| Pre-op | 50.33% | 22.81° | 6.8 |
| Post-op | 79.61% | 8.54° | 2.4 |
| T=-12.08 p <0.00001 | T=6.90 p <0.00001 | p <0.05 |
Table 2
Comparison of demography, results and complications of our study with other studies
| Demography | Anterior vertebral height restoration | Improvement in angle of kyphosis | VAS drop | Complications | |
| Our series | 59 Patients, 19 males, 40 females | From 50.33% to 79.61% | From 22.81° to 8.54°=63% improvement | 6.8 to 2.4=4.4 | Asymptomatic cement leak in 15% cases |
| Chia-Wei Yu et al . [ 27 ] | 187 patients 65 males, 122 females | From 52% to 74.5% p <0.05 | From 14.4° to 6.7°=53% improvement | 7.7 to 2.2=5.5 | Cement leak in 11.5% cases |
| Klezl et al . [ 28 ] | 105 patients, 37 males, 68 females | NA | From 11.6° to 10.9°=6% improvement | 8.2 to 4.4=3.8 | 11 patients ( 10.4%) with minor complications |
| Saxena et al . [ 29 ] | 135 patients | From 30.62% to 16. 19% (Loss of vertebral height) | 17.41° to 10.59°=39% improvement | 6.7 to 2.2=4.5 | 6 patients with cement embolism, 65 incidence of cement leak, 3 patients with adjacent level fracture |
| Ledlie Jt et al . [30] | 117 patients | Significant restoration; >10% increase in 84% of patients | Asymptomatic cement extravasation in 11.3% patients |
Following osteoporotic compression fracture, anterior vertebral height decreased to an average of 50.33% (11.11-79.07%; sample SD=14.68). Postoperatively, anterior vertebral height improved to 79.61% of normal subjects (Range: 50-97.67%). At p <0.05, the result was significant with t=-12.08 and p <0.00001 ( Table 1 ). In our series, the patients experienced quick and significant reduction in pain. Changes in VAS following treatment was significant with p <0.001, and the relief sustained during subsequent follow-up.
On first follow-up, >5° increase in Cobb’s angle was observed in 4 (6.78%) patients. At 1 year follow up, there were no significant ( p >0.1) changes in radiological parameters compared to postoperative value. Anterior vertebral height and kyphotic angle were maintained to >95% of post-operative values. Overall, the incidence of cement leak in our study was 15.25% (9 patients), while 6 patients had asymptomatic paravertebral leak, and 2 patients had leak in disc space. One patient had venous embolism. There was no incidence of epidural leak. All patients had uneventful post-operation period.
Discussion
Fragility fracture of spine in osteoporotic patients is of great concern and accounts for 50% of the fractures. Intractable pain and deformity are the most common encountered problem and imparts the great repercussion over the quality of life [ 14 , 15 ]. Conventional treatment of osteoporotic compression fracture (OCF) is by conservative mean, in the form of rest, pain killers, orthosis and rehabilitation. Galibert et al . introduced the PMMA injection (vertebroplasty) technique for first time to manage the cervical hemangioma [ 16 ].
In a subsequent year, this method was widely used by Jensen et al . for treating the osteoporotic compression fractures (OCF) [ 17 ]. Management of OCF is focused on pain control and functional recovery. Conservative treatment in the form of analgesia, pain, and bracing saves the patient from anesthesia and surgery related risks, but the drawbacks are complications related to immobilization, and kyphosis leading to sagittal imbalance, and an increased risk of OCF at other levels secondary to disturbed spinal column biomechanics [ 18 - 20 ].
Owing to above mentioned drawbacks cement augmentation of OCF in the form of vertebroplasty/balloon kyphoplasty is now an established form of treatment. Wang et al . concluded that high viscosity cement vertebroplasty and balloon kyphoplasty were safe and effective in improving quality of life and relieving pain [ 21 ]. Until recently, the biomechanical studies have been done mainly for the transpedicular approach for cement augmentation of OCF. Since now the extrapedicular approach has been developed recently; nowadays, the question becomes relevant to discuss the comparison of biomechanical studies of both.
An in vitro cadaveric biomechanical study for transpedicular and extrapedicular approaches has shown that extrapedicular approach had superiority in height restoration [ 22 ]. The transpedicular approach posed difficulty in higher thoracic vertebral body (T9 and above) due to relatively smaller pedicle with and lateral angulation. So the above limiting factors are responsible for suboptimal balloon insertion by transpedicular approach due to more centric position of lateral cortex of pedicle. At these levels, the extrapedicular approach seems more relevant. Therefore, the extrapedicular approach is safer and more feasible even in higher thoracic regions [ 23 ].
Unilateral extrapedicular lumbar kyphoplasty has almost similar clinical outcomes for the thoracic as well as lumber vertebral compression fractures. But due to significant anatomical variations between these two vertebrae, a cautious unilateral extrapedicular approach is needed for lumbar region [ 24 ]. It is suggested to use extrapedicular approach for thoracic and transpedicular approach for lumbar vertebral compression fractures, because of potential risk of segmental artery damage in lumbar area by extrapedicular approach [ 25 ].
Cement leakage is a common problem, although it is mostly asymptomatic. Venous embolism and unrestricted posterior flow of cement in spinal canal can have serious outcomes too. Reported leakage rate is variable, ranging from 19% to 88% for vertebroplasty and 7% to 52% for balloon kyphoplasty. Studies using CT to investigate cement leakage usually report much higher rates. In our study, we observed 15.25% incidence of cement leakage with no leakage in epidural, foraminal or pedicular region. Vogl et al . has evaluated the role of CT guided kyphoplasty for reducing the cement leakage and found it an effective method [ 26 ].
Our series focused on clinical and radiological outcome analysis of OCF following balloon kyphoplasty through extrapedicular approach. Unilateral extrapedicular approach was found to be as effective as conventional transpedicular approach in restoring vertebral height, maintaining sagittal alignment and clinical recovery, the added advantages have less risk for epidural cement leak, the need for single balloon, less radiation exposure and a decreased duration of surgery. This approach is commonly utilized by interventional radiologists to perform vertebral biopsies.
Dorso-lumbar junction was the most common location (78.69%) in our series. Back pain, assessed by VAS score was shown to be improved significantly ( p <0.05) within 24 hours of balloon kyphoplasty. Our results are similar to previously published literatures of balloon kyphoplasty as shown in Table 2 .
Study of Chia-Wei Yu et al . had the less percentage of cement leakage in comparison to our study, but the VAS drop, anterior vertebral height restoration and improvement in angle of kyphosis were comparable [ 27 ]. Klezl Z et al . did not find any significant gain in kyphosis correction, other than VAS drop and minor complications [ 28 ]. Study of Saxena et al . had relatively higher complications and less kyphotic correction, but the VAS drop was similar to our study [ 29 ].
Study by Ledlie et al . also had comparable outcomes when compared with our series. So our series supported a significant improvement in VAS drop, sagittal alignment and anterior vertebral height restoration. We completed our study with few imitations. We had relatively small number of cases and lack of the comparison groups. Moreover, we did not include the upper thoracic level (T9 and above) and single level; therefore, we could not speculate the same result in upper thoracic level and multiple level OCF. Radiation exposure and duration of surgery were not calculated in our study too, and it seems to be another limitation of this study.
Unilateral extrapedicular balloon kyphoplasty can be used as a relatively safer and practicable method for the management of osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture. Yet, we faced little difficulty in needle placement in kyphotic vertebrae. Furthermore, it is as effective as conventional techniques in restoring anterior vertebral height, alignment and angle of kyphosis along with added advantages of no risk of epidural cement leakage in cases with intact posterior cortex and need of single balloon.
Conflict of Interest:
None declared.
References
1 Kondo KL Osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures and vertebral augmentation. Seminars in interventional radiology 2008 Thieme Medical Publishers 10.1055/s-0028-1103000 PMC3036532 21326583
2 Kim HS Kim SH Ju CI Kim SW Lee SM Shin H The role of bone cement augmentation in the treatment of chronic symptomatic osteoporotic compression fracture J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2010 48 6 490 5 21430974 10.3340/jkns.2010.48.6.490 PMC3053542
3 Papanastassiou ID Filis A Gerochristou MA Vrionis FD Controversial issues in kyphoplasty and vertebroplasty in osteoporotic vertebral fractures Biomed Res Int. 2014 2014 934206 24724106 10.1155/2014/934206 PMC3960523
4 Hiwatashi A Westesson PL Yoshiura T Noguchi T Togao O Yamashita K Kyphoplasty and vertebroplasty produce the same degree of height restoration AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2009 30 4 669 73 19131409 10.3174/ajnr.A1442 PMC7051743
5 Lieberman IH Dudeney S Reinhardt MK Bell G Initial outcome and efficacy of "kyphoplasty" in the treatment of painful osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 2001 26 14 1631 8 11464159 10.1097/00007632-200107150-00026
6 Shindle MK Gardner MJ Koob J Bukata S Cabin JA Lane JM Vertebral height restoration in osteoporotic compression fractures: kyphoplasty balloon tamp is superior to postural correction alone Osteoporos Int. 2006 17 12 1815 9 16983458 10.1007/s00198-006-0195-x
7 Lee IJ Choi AL Yie MY Yoon JY Jeon EY Koh SH CT evaluation of local leakage of bone cement after percutaneous kyphoplasty and vertebroplasty Acta Radiol. 2010 51 6 649 54 20528649 10.3109/02841851003620366
8 Liu T Li Z Su Q Hai Y Cement leakage in osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures with cortical defect using high-viscosity bone cement during unilateral percutaneous kyphoplasty surgery Medicine (Baltimore). 2017 96 25 e7216 28640112 10.1097/MD.0000000000007216 PMC5484220
9 Choe DH Marom EM Ahrar K Truong MT Madewell JE Pulmonary embolism of polymethyl methacrylate during percutaneous vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2004 183 4 1097 102 15385313 10.2214/ajr.183.4.1831097
10 Chiras J Depriester C Weill A Sola-Martinez MT Deramond H Percutaneous vertebral surgery Technics and indications. J Neuroradiol. 1997 24 1 45 59 9303944
11 Brugieres P Gaston A Heran F Voisin MC Marsault C Percutaneous biopsies of the thoracic spine under CT guidance: transcostovertebral approach J Comput Assist Tomogr. 1990 14 3 446 8 2335614 10.1097/00004728-199005000-00023
12 Yang HL Niu GQ Liang DC Wang GL Meng B Chen L The contrast study between single and double balloon bilateral dilatation of kyphoplasty Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2004 42 21 1299 302 15634429
13 Ryu KS Huh HY Jun SC Park CK Single-balloon kyphoplasty in osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures: far-lateral extrapedicular approach J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2009 45 2 122 6 19274126 10.3340/jkns.2009.45.2.122 PMC2651548
14 Cook DJ Guyatt GH Adachi JD Clifton J Griffith LE Epstein RS Quality of life issues in women with vertebral fractures due to osteoporosis Arthritis Rheum. 1993 36 6 750 6 8507215 10.1002/art.1780360603
15 Gold DT The clinical impact of vertebral fractures: quality of life in women with osteoporosis Bone. 1996 18 3 Suppl 185S 189S 8777086 10.1016/8756-3282(95)00500-5
16 Galibert P Deramond H Rosat P Le Gars D Preliminary note on the treatment of vertebral angioma by percutaneous acrylic vertebroplasty Neurochirurgie. 1987 33 2 166 8 3600949
17 Jensen ME Evans AJ Mathis JM Kallmes DF Cloft HJ Dion JE Percutaneous polymethylmethacrylate vertebroplasty in the treatment of osteoporotic vertebral body compression fractures: technical aspects AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 1997 18 10 1897 904 9403451 PMC8337380
18 Tang H Zhao J Hao C Osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures: surgery versus non-operative management J Int Med Res. 2011 39 4 1438 47 21986146 10.1177/147323001103900432
19 Alexandru D So W Evaluation and management of vertebral compression fractures Perm J. 2012 16 4 46 51 23251117 10.7812/tpp/12-037 PMC3523935
20 Wang H Sribastav SS Ye F Yang C Wang J Liu H Comparison of Percutaneous Vertebroplasty and Balloon Kyphoplasty for the Treatment of Single Level Vertebral Compression Fractures: A Meta-analysis of the Literature Pain Physician. 2015 18 3 209 22 26000665
21 Krølner B Toft B Vertebral bone loss: an unheeded side effect of therapeutic bed rest Clin Sci (Lond). 1983 64 5 537 40 6831837 10.1042/cs0640537
22 Erkan S Wu C Mehbod AA Cho W Transfeldt EE Biomechanical comparison of transpedicular versus extrapedicular vertebroplasty using polymethylmethacrylate J Spinal Disord Tech. 2010 23 3 180 5 20065863 10.1097/BSD.0b013e31819c48a4
23 Kim HS Kim SW Ju CI Balloon Kyphoplasty through Extrapedicular Approach in the Treatment of Middle Thoracic Osteoporotic Compression Fracture: T5-T8 Level J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2007 42 5 363 6 19096570 10.3340/jkns.2007.42.5.363 PMC2588193
24 Cho SM Nam YS Cho BM Lee SY Oh SM Kim MK Unilateral extrapedicular vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty in lumbar compression fractures: technique, anatomy and preliminary results J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2011 49 5 273 7 21716899 10.3340/jkns.2011.49.5.273 PMC3115147
25 Vogl TJ Proschek D Schwarz W Mack M Hochmuth K CT-guided percutaneous vertebroplasty in the therapy of vertebral compression fractures Eur Radiol. 2006 16 4 797 803 16333624 10.1007/s00330-005-0021-4
26 Yu CW Hsieh MK Chen LH Niu CC Fu TS Lai PL Percutaneous balloon kyphoplasty for the treatment of vertebral compression fractures BMC Surg. 2014 14 3 24423182 10.1186/1471-2482-14-3 PMC3922728
27 Klezl Z Clamp JA Becker J Jones M Calthorpe D Bommireddy R Impact of kyphoplasty treatment for vertebral compression fractures on pain and function in 105 patients Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2011 78 6 551 5 22217409
28 Saxena BP Shah BV Joshi SP Outcome of percutaneous balloon kyphoplasty in vertebral compression fractures Indian J Orthop. 2015 49 4 458 64 26229169 10.4103/0019-5413.159673 PMC4510802
29 Ledlie JT Renfro M Balloon kyphoplasty: one-year outcomes in vertebral body height restoration, chronic pain, and activity levels J Neurosurg. 2003 98 1Suppl 36 42 12546386 10.3171/spi.2003.98.1.0036