Efficiency Enhancement in Peptide Hydrogelators: The Crucial Role of Side Chain Hydrogen Bonding Over Aromatic π-π Interactions.

Short peptide assemblies that form supramolecular hydrogels are stabilized by both intermolecular noncovalent interactions among amino acid side chains and hydrogen bonding between peptide backbone amides. Previous research has emphasized the inclusion of aromatic amino acids in short peptide sequences, positing that aromatic π-π interactions contribute significantly to inducing efficient hydrogelation i.e., at low minimum gelation concentrations (MGCs). However, herein, we demonstrate that additional hydrogen bonding interactions from amino acid side chains play a more pivotal role in the efficiency of peptide hydrogelation compared to aromatic π-π interactions. We investigated two sets of Fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl (Fmoc)-functionalized α-synuclein and human islet amyloid peptide fragments [Fmoc-NVGGAVVT (Syn-N) and Fmoc-NFGAIL (IAP-N)], substituting asparagine (N) with phenylalanine (Syn-F/IAP-F), alanine (Syn-A/IAP-A), and glutamine (Syn-Q/IAP-Q). This allowed us to explore the effects of aromatic (π-system), aliphatic (hydrophobic), and hydrogen bonding effects with varying chain lengths on hydrogel formation. Our results reveal that Syn-N and Syn-Q exhibit MGC of 0.03 and 0.05 wt %, respectively, classifying them as super hydrogelators (MGC < 0.1 wt %). These values are 4.0-6.6-fold lower than Syn-F and Syn-A, with Syn-N demonstrating greater efficiency than Syn-Q. Similarly, IAP-N exhibited a substantial decrease in MGC by 8.75, 3.75, and 2.5 folds compared to IAP-A, IAP-F, and IAP-Q, respectively. Experimental evidence and molecular dynamic simulation suggest that -CO-NH2 of asparagine side chains effectively engaged in hydrogen bonding, thereby immobilizing water molecules at low gelator concentrations. Although glutamine shares similar -CO-NH2 functionality, its hydrogelation efficiency is less pronounced compared to asparagine, likely due to its longer alkyl chain, which may hinder the formation of a hydrogen bonding network in the self-assembled structure compared to asparagine-containing peptides. These findings offer valuable insights for designing efficient peptide hydrogelators or lowering MGCs by substituting amino acids with asparagine/glutamine in peptide sequences. Additionally, modifying peptide properties through asparagine/glutamine substitution could optimize hydrogel properties for specific applications.