Diagnostic accuracy of basic lung ultrasound in breathless patients over 60 years of age; stressing the protocol.

Introduction

Emergency department differentiation of pulmonary oedema from chronic obstructive airways disease causing acute breathlessness is inaccurate 25% of the time despite clinical acumen, clinician-reported chest x-ray and ECG. This research investigates whether a basic lung ultrasound protocol (LUS) could improve identification of pulmonary oedema in breathless elderly patients. Method: Researchers prospectively sampled patients over 60 years, describing any breathlessness on presentation to a suburban emergency department. LUS studies were acquired by experienced or novice sonologists, interpreted by a blinded reviewer and compared with cardiologist chart audit for diagnosis at admission (gold standard). The admitting doctor's diagnosis, blinded to LUS, was compared with the chart audit result.

Results

204 LUS were collected, 145 by experienced sonologist and 59 by inexperienced. Diagnostic accuracy compared to cardiologist audit was 86.2% (95% CI 80.9 to 90.3), significantly higher than 70.2%, diagnostic accuracy for admission diagnosis, difference in proportion of 16% (95%CI 7.7 to 24.4%).

Conclusion

A simple lung scanning protocol can help exclude pulmonary oedema in any breathless elderly patient.