Secondary Contouring for the Butterfly Graft: Improving Form and Preserving Function.

OBJECTIVE

The butterfly graft (BFG) secondary contouring procedure addresses external nasal irregularities following the primary BFG surgery. We explore demographic factors associated with the desire for secondary contouring and assess patient-reported outcomes following the procedure.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of 374 patients undergoing BFG between April 2020 and April 2023 identified 10 individuals electing for secondary contouring. Demographics, Nasal Obstruction Symptoms Evaluation (NOSE) scores, Rhinosinusitis Disability Index (RSDI), and decision regret scale (DRS) were collected and reported.

RESULTS

Secondary contouring rate was 2.7% of total cases. The majority of patients desiring BFG secondary contouring were white females (90%). NOSE scores significantly improved post-primary surgery (mean change: 51.7, SD: 14.01, p-value: <0.05). Although overall NOSE scores remained improved after secondary contouring (mean change: 47.2, SD: 18.84, p-value: <0.05) compared with their preoperative NOSE scores, one patient (10%) reported worse score after secondary contouring. Four patients (40%) reported worsening after secondary contouring compared with after initial BFG surgery. DRS indicated minimal regret from patients.

CONCLUSION

BFG secondary contouring is a valuable option for patients with external nasal complaints, providing improvements in nasal appearance and durable improvement in breathing outcomes. We emphasize the importance of patient counseling and appropriate patient selection. Our results suggest that patients should expect a slight worsening of NOSE scores following secondary contouring, but that significant worsening is a low risk.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 4: Case series Laryngoscope, 135:1066-1071, 2025.