Recording nasal muscle F waves and electromyographic activity of the facial muscles: a comparison of two methods used for intraoperative monitoring of facial nerve function.

OBJECT: A comparison of two electrophysiological methods used to assess facial nerve function intraoperatively was conducted in 33 patients with tumors of the cerebellopontine angle.

METHODS

All 33 patients had presented with normal facial nerve function preoperatively. After general anesthesia had been induced by a mixture of midazolam and fentanyl, continual online EMG recordings from the orbicularis oculi and oris muscles were alternated with nasal muscle F-wave recordings. Facial nerve outcomes, assessed using a modified House-Brackmann scale, varied among good (48%), moderate (18%), and poor (33%). Analysis of electromyographic (EMG) data resulted in a significant correlation between the finding of only transient manipulation-evoked activity and a good outcome, whereas in cases in which there was poor outcome, an increase in the amplitude or duration of ongoing activity was detected. A permanent loss of nasal muscle F waves specifically appeared to indicate a severe dysfunction of the facial nerve that was linked to a poor outcome. All patients with latency and/or amplitude changes or even a transient loss of the F wave achieved good or moderate facial nerve outcomes. A transient loss of the F wave, however, was detected significantly more frequently in patients with moderate outcomes. None of these patients exhibited normal facial function (House-Brackmann Grade I) postoperatively.

CONCLUSIONS

Online EMG monitoring can provide some information on imminent or even present damage to the facial nerve intraoperatively. The diagnostic sensitivity, specificity, and positive predictive values of a permanent F-wave loss, however, are much higher than those of EMG monitoring. Additionally, this loss of the F wave is supposed to be transient if the surgical procedure is stopped until the F wave recovers. Therefore, F-wave monitoring serves to alert the surgeon that the facial nerve is about to receive a lesion.