Carotid endarterectomy. Who needs it?

Although carotid endarterectomy is one of the most frequently performed operations in this country, recent evidence casts doubt on its advisability, particularly for patients with ocular manifestations of cerebral ischemia. The following evidence is that: the risk of future stroke in untreated patients with amaurosis fugax, retinal plaques, and infarcts is less than 3% per year, far lower than that expected for cerebral (hemispheric) transient ischemic attacks (TIAs); the perioperative risk of stroke and death after endarterectomy may be much higher than previously suspected; and aspirin is a comparatively risk-free and moderately effective alternative to endarterectomy. Because of the questions raised about the risk-to-benefit ratio of endarterectomy, patients with ocular manifestations of cerebral ischemia should be considered for this operation only as part of a proposed randomized collaborative study.