Diagnostic yield and therapeutic impact of open lung biopsy in the critically ill patient.

BACKGROUND

Open lung biopsy (OLB) is a rare procedure in intensive care units (ICUs) for therapeutic management of acute respiratory failure (ARF). The purpose of this study was to analyze the diagnostic yield, therapeutic contribution and complications of OLB in ICU patients with ARF of unclear etiology, including acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) and ARDS mimics.

METHODS

Retrospective study conducted in a 10-bed ICU over a 13-year period. Patients undergoing OLB for ARF with undiagnosed infiltrates on CT scan were included. ARDS was defined according to Berlin criteria, and ARDS mimics as a condition looking like ARDS except for the presence of a known cause. OLB was contributive when the OLB findings yielded a specific diagnosis resulting in a change in the patients' treatment or management.

RESULTS

Forty six patients were included (sex ratio = 2.5, median and [interquartile range] age = 69 [59-77] years, and admission SAPS II = 42 [33-50]. ARF corresponded to ARDS in 22 patients and to ARDS mimics in 16. OLB yielded 61 diagnoses in 45 patients including diffuse alveolar damage (N = 21), lung fibrosis (N = 18), and organizing pneumonia (N = 11). OLB was contributive in 37 patients (80%), including 13/16 ARDS mimickers. The main contributions of OLB were the introduction or maintenance of steroids (N = 32) and discontinuation of antibiotics (N = 9). In 4 patients OLB resulted directly in the decision to forgo life-sustaining treatment. OLB complications occurred in 16 patients (35%), in one case associated with fatal outcome.

CONCLUSION

OLB can play a useful role in the management of ICU patients with ARF of undetermined origin, including ARDS mimickers. Further studies should be done to identify the groups of ICU patients likely to benefit from the procedure with minimum risk.