Distinct profile of cell-free DNA in malignant pleural effusion of non-small cell lung cancer and its impact on clinical genetic testing.

Cell-free DNA (cfDNA) in supernatant of pleural effusion from advanced NSCLC patients has been proved as surrogate sample detecting therapeutic targets as well as tumor mutation burden (TMB). As recently reported, cfDNA in pleural effusion supernatant is superior to plasma in TMB evaluation. It is reasonable to hypothesize that cfDNA profile in pleural effusion (PE) and plasma might be different. It remains to be elucidated why cfDNA in PE supernatant impacts on genetic analysis. Consequently, the approach dealing with cfDNA from PE supernatant might need to be different from that for plasma cfDNA in order to obtain accurate clinical genetic testing result.

Methods

Pleural effusion samples from 32 patients with stage IV lung adenocarcinoma were collected. Supernatant and sediment were processed separately to extract Cell-free DNA as well as sediment DNA (PE-S). cfDNA from pleural effusion was analyzed by Agilent 2100 bioanalyzer. Libraries were prepared by 1) direct use of the total cfDNA without fragmentation step (PE-FL) or 2) use of full-length cfDNA fragmented to 150-250bp (PE-F), 3) use of cfDNA fragments enriched to ~167bp (PE-E167) as well as 4) use of cfDNA fragments larger than 500bp enriched (PE-E500). All samples were subjected to targeted next-generation sequencing (NGS) with a panel of 448 cancer-related genes as well as a panel of 10 NSCLC driver genes.

Results

cfDNA were successfully extracted from 30 MPE samples. cfDNA displayed distinct profile in supernatant of malignant pleural effusion from that of plasma cfDNA. No statistical difference in detection of hotspot variations between PE-E167 and PE-F by 448-gene or 10-gene panel. While TMB from PE-F samples was significantly higher than that from PE-E167 and PE-FL. Higher TMB from PE-F was resulted from cancer-unspecific variants with low allele frequency (0.1%-1%) which were mainly introduced by long-fragment cfDNA. Similar genetic profile was observed between paired cfDNA of PE-FL and cfDNA of PE-E167.

Conclusion

Long-fragment cfDNA in the PE supernatant will introduce low abundant cancer unrelated variants which leads overestimation of TMB. Paired PE-FL and PE-E167 gave comparable outcomes. Direct use of the total cfDNA without fragmentation step (PE-FL) is recommended for library preparation of NGS testing in clinical practice to exclude interference from long fragments of the cfDNA.