Evaluation of new approach to enhance visualization performance in cataract surgery: 3D visualization system with coaxial illumination.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the visualization performance of different approaches, including the 3D visualization system with coaxial illumination and the 3D system or microscope with standard illumination.

SETTING

Fuzhou Eye Hospital, Fuzhou City, China.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

METHODS

This 2-part performance assessment for visualization composed of an objective analysis using surgical video images and a subjective survey collecting feedback from surgeons. Data of each eye were obtained with 3 approaches: standard operating microscope with standard illumination (SOM-S), 3D visualization system with standard illumination (3D-S), and 3D visualization system with coaxial illumination (3D-C).

RESULTS

112 eyes (107 cases) and 6 cataract surgeons were involved. The red reflex value was markedly greater in the 3D-C approach compared with other 2 approaches ( P < .001). Compared with the SOM-S approach, the red reflex increased by 55%, 57%, and 53% in the 3D-C approach, corresponding to nuclear grades of II, III, and IV, respectively. In the questionnaire survey, red reflex scores were consistently significantly higher in the 3D-C approach than those in the others ( P < .001). Depth of field was enhanced in both 3D approaches compared with the SOM-S approach ( P < .05). The only minor advantage of the SOM system over the 3D-C approach was in the surrounding field clarity score, and the difference was not statistically significant ( P = 1.000).

CONCLUSIONS

The 3D-C approach significantly increased the red reflex in both objective and subjective assessments. Surgeon responses also showed a superior performance for the 3D-C approach.