Barcelona line. A multicentre validation study of a facial projection reference in orthognathic surgery.

The purpose of this study was to validate an already published facial anteroposterior reference: upper incisor (UI) to soft tissue plane or so-called Barcelona line (BL) to trace the most aesthetic sagittal position of the maxilla. A cross-sectional multicentre evaluation of Caucasian patients from Spain and Brazil with different anteroposterior maxillary positions was designed. Sagittal images in natural head orientation of grouped patients according to the horizontal distance from the UI to BL were ranked by healthcare professionals and non-professional Caucasian raters according to the aesthetic perception of each profile, using a digital survey. Seventy-four raters (50 laypeople, 12 orthodontists, and 12 maxillofacial surgeons) rated 40 profiles. The best-rated profile corresponded to group 3 (0-4 mm UI-BL) with 61.8% of positive evaluations, followed by group 4 (≥ 4 mm UI-BL): with 61.1%. On the other hand, group 1 (≤-4 mm UI-BL) was the worst-ranked profile with 71.8% of negative evaluations, followed by group 2 (-4-0 mm UI-BL): with 59.6% of negative evaluations. The correlation between the mean assessment score and UI-BL showed a moderately-strong association (r = 0.68, p < 0.001). The inter-rater reliability of assessment (74 evaluators) was moderate (k = 0.49, 95% CI: 0.39 to 0.59). The results suggest that protrusive middle-third facial profiles are preferable. The BL is proposed as a simple, individualised, and reproducible tool to trace an aesthetic sagittal position of the maxilla in orthognathic surgery.