Does the presence of QAC genes in staphylococci affect the efficacy of disinfecting solutions used by orthokeratology lens wearers?

BACKGROUND/AIM: There has been increasing evidence of the emergence of antiseptic resistance mediated by quaternary ammonium compound (QAC) resistance genes, which may reduce the efficacy of disinfection. Although the presence of QAC-positive staphylococci has been shown to be elevated in contact lens wearers, the efficacy of multipurpose solutions (MPS) against such isolates has not been determined. This study investigated the efficacy of four MPS for rigid gas permeable (RGP) lenses against staphylococci-harbouring QAC genes.

METHODS: Ability to reduce viability by three or more log reductions of four MPS for RGP lenses was tested against 60 disinfectant-resistant gene-positive staphylococci, comprising 38 coagulase-negative staphylococci (CNS) (17 ITALIC! qacA/B, 7 ITALIC! smr, 5 ITALIC! qacH, 9 habouring two or more genes) and 22 ITALIC! Staphylococcus aureus (16 ITALIC! qacA/B, 4 ITALIC! smr, 2 ITALIC! qacA/B+ ITALIC! smr)). 60 gene-negative isolates of staphylococci (30 CNS and 30 ITALIC! S aureus) were used as controls. Minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) and minimum bactericidal concentrations (MBCs) of these four MPS were determined.

RESULTS: Although there was some variation between solutions, all failed to achieve a 3-log reduction in some ITALIC! S aureus and CNS isolates. Strains harbouring disinfectant-resistant genes were significantly less likely to be reduced by 3 logs by three of the solutions. Overall, the MIC and MBC of the four MPS against gene-positive clinical isolates were significantly higher than those of gene-negative isolates.

CONCLUSION: The efficacy of MPS solutions for RGP lenses against staphylococci varied. The presence of disinfectant-resistance genes significantly adversely affected disinfecting capacity of RGP solutions.