[Validity of diagnoses of mental disorders by primary care physicians].

BACKGROUND AND

OBJECTIVE

Even in young adult age, psychological disorders are highly prevalent. Family doctors and gynaecologists are the physicians most often consulted by young women. Hence, they have a special responsibility to diagnose psychiatric disorders and--if necessary--to refer to a specialist.

PATIENTS AND

METHODS

In a prospective epidemiological study, 342 young women (between 18 and 25 years of age) were questioned two times with a structured interview (F-DIPS) designed for mental disorders. In the time period (1997 and 1998), we also investigated, by analysing personal health insurance data, primary-care physicians' diagnoses and payments for services rendered. The diagnoses were compared.

RESULTS

There was only a small accordance between F-DIPS and claimcards. Ambulant treating doctors diagnosed somatoform disorders in 28 % of the young women (F-DIPS: 3, 8 %). The F- DIPS found mostly phobic disorders (29 %) (claimcards: 6,1 %). A disorder-specific therapy was only rarely initiated. The treatment (psychotherapy and/or drug therapy) of women with psychiatric disorders appeared to be insufficient.

CONCLUSION

The study indicates that primary-care physicians should be urgently trained in psychiatric diagnostics und therapy.