An exception to the rule "no association between antibiotic resistance and decreased disinfectant microbicidal efficacy": Orthophthalaldehyde (OPA) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa isolated from ICU and paraplegic patients.

BACKGROUND

Antibiotic resistance and decreased susceptibility to disinfectants are not usually associated in microorganisms, but we have found an exception to this rule: P. aeruginosa versus orthophthalaldehyde (OPA).

METHODS

Bactericidal effect of OPA was measured at 10 minutes on endodoncy files contaminated with an ATCC strain (control) or 206 strains of P. aeruginosa recently isolated from 206 ICU and paraplegic patients in a tertiary university hospital, in two consecutive years.

RESULTS

Differences in bactericidal effect of OPA were found between the strains isolated each year (decreased susceptibility in the first period), but in both years the statistical differences (p < 0.05) were maintained according to whether the strains were "susceptible" to antibiotics, "resistant" (to one family of antibiotics) or "multi-resistant" (resistant to more than one family of antibiotics), exhibiting a reduction in their OPA susceptibility in parallel to an increase of their antibiotic resistance. In contrast, there were no differences depending on the type of sample (sputum, urine, faeces, pharynx) or of patient (paraplegic or ICU: adult, newborn, burn). Finally we selected 15 strains with an OPA effect below 3.5 log10 at 10 minutes and repeated the study with an OPA exposure of 15 minutes. In these conditions OPA showed a total bactericidal effect on these P. aeruginosa strains.

CONCLUSIONS

There was an association between antibiotic resistance and decreased OPA susceptibility. This normally does not require an increase in disinfection time, but, for endoscope disinfection or instruments from colonized/infected patients with resistant/multiresistant P. aeruginosa, we consider it better to use 15 min of OPA. Regular tests (e.g., once every 12 months) with germ-carriers, should be performed to assess ecological changes in susceptibility to high level disinfectants and must include not only ATCC strains, but also recently isolated microorganisms with different antibiotic sensitivities (susceptible, resistant and multi-resistant).