False-positive results in transcranial motor evoked potentials for outcome prognostication during surgery for supratentorial lesions.

During monitoring of motor evoked potentials (MEP) elicited by transcranial electrical stimulation (TES) for prognostication of postoperative motor deficit, significant MEP changes without postoperative deterioration of motor function represent false-positive results. We aimed to investigate this phenomenon in a large series of patients who underwent resection of supratentorial lesions. TES was applied in 264 patients during resection of motor-eloquent supratentorial lesions. MEP were recorded bilaterally from arm, leg, and/ or facial muscles. The threshold criterion was applied assessing percentage increase in threshold level, which was considered significant if being > 20% higher on affected side than on the unaffected side. Subcortical stimulation was additionally applied to estimate the distance to corticospinal tract. Motor function was evaluated at 24 h after surgery and at 3-month follow-up. Patients with false-positive results were analyzed regarding tumor location, tumor volume, and characteristics of the monitoring. MEP were recorded from 399 muscles (264 arm muscles, 75 leg muscles, and 60 facial muscles). Motor function was unchanged postoperatively in 359 muscles in 228 patients. Among these cases, the threshold level did not change significantly in 354 muscles in 224 patients, while it increased significantly in the remaining 5 muscles in 4 patients (abductor pollicis brevis in all four patients and orbicularis oris in one patient), leading to a false-positive rate of 1.1%. Tumor volume, opening the ventricle, and negative subcortical stimulation did not significantly correlate with false-positive results, while the tumor location in the parietal lobe dorsal to the postcentral gyrus correlated significantly (p = 0.012, odds ratio 11.2, 95% CI 1.8 to 69.8). False-negative results took place in 1.1% of cases in a large series of TES-MEP monitoring using the threshold criterion. Tumor location in the parietal lobe dorsal to the postcentral gyrus was the only predictor of false-positive results.