Evaluation of three Aspergillus antibody assays for screening of chronic pulmonary aspergillosis: prospective diagnostic accuracy study.

OBJECTIVES

Chronic pulmonary aspergillosis (CPA) is a frequent complication of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB), particularly in high-burden settings where access to reliable serological diagnostics remains limited. We evaluated the diagnostic performance of two immunochromatographic technology (ICT) lateral flow assays (LFAs) and an ELISA for CPA screening among patients with active or previously treated PTB.

METHODS

In this two-year prospective multicentre diagnostic evaluation, serum from adults with prior or active PTB was tested using the Era Biology Aspergillus IgG ICT LFA, LDBio Aspergillus IgG/IgM ICT LFA, and Bordier Aspergillus fumigatus IgG ELISA. CPA diagnosis was established using a consensus composite reference standard incorporating clinical, immunological, radiological, and microbiological criteria. The Bordier ELISA was used as part of the immunological component of the consensus CPA diagnosis, with a cutoff optical density of ≥1.0. Diagnostic accuracy, agreement statistics, receiver operating characteristic analysis, and latent class analysis (LCA) were performed.

RESULTS

Among 340 participants, 24 (7.06%) had CPA. Proportion of participants with positive antibody tests among all tested individuals were 6.76% for LDBio ICT LFA, 20.0% for Era Biology ICT LFA, and 11.47% for Bordier ELISA. Against consensus CPA diagnosis, Bordier ELISA showed 87.50% sensitivity and 94.30% specificity, LDBio ICT LFA 58.33% sensitivity and 97.15% specificity, and Era Biology LFA 66.67% sensitivity and 83.54% specificity. LCA estimated CPA prevalence at 7.72%. LCA-derived sensitivities and specificities were 86.58% and 99.92% for LDBio ICT LFA, 83.39% and 85.31% for Era Biology LFA, and 79.10% and 94.19% for Bordier ELISA.

CONCLUSIONS

The Bordier ELISA showed high sensitivity and specificity, while the LDBio ICT LFA demonstrated very high specificity with strong LCA-derived performance. These findings support the use of ELISA for laboratory diagnosis and ICT as a point-of-care screening tool for CPA in resource-limited settings. Era Biology Aspergillus IgG LFA demonstrated moderate sensitivity and acceptable diagnostic performance, indicating its potential utility as a supplementary screening assay for CPA in settings where rapid, point-of-care testing is required.