Calcium Phosphate Bone Void Filler Increases Threaded Suture Anchor Pullout Strength: A Biomechanical Study.

PURPOSE: To compare the response to cyclical loading and ultimate pull-out strength of threaded suture anchor with and without calcium phosphate bone void filler augmentation in a polyurethane foam block model and in vitro proximal humerus cadaveric model.

METHODS

This controlled biomechanical study consisted of 2 parts: (1) preliminary polyurethane foam block model, and (2) in vitro cadaveric humeri model. The preliminary foam block model intended to mimic osteoporotic bone using a 0.12 g/mL foam material. Half of the foam block models were first filled with injectable calcium phosphate bone substitute material (CP-BSM), whereas the other half were not augmented with CP-BSM. Each specimen was then instrumented with a threaded suture anchor. The same technique and process was performed in a matched cadaveric humeri model. Testing then consisted of a stepwise, increasing axial load protocol for a total of 40 cycles. If the anchor remained intact after cyclic loading, the repair was loaded to failure. The number of completed cycles, failure load, and failure modes were compared between groups.

RESULTS

Average pull-out strength for suture anchor with CP-BSM in the osteoporotic foam block model was significantly higher at 332.68 N ± 47.61 compared with the average pull-out strength of suture anchor without CP-BSM at 144.38 N ± 14.58 (P = .005). In the matched cadaveric humeri model, average pull-out strength for suture anchor with CP-BSM was significantly higher at 274.07 N ± 102.07 compared with the average pull-out strength of suture anchor without CP-BSM at 138.53 N ± 109.87 (P = .029).

CONCLUSIONS

In this time zero, biomechanical study, augmentation of osteoporotic foam block and cadaveric bone with calcium phosphate bone substitute material significantly increases pull-out strength of threaded suture anchors.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Considering concerns about suture anchor pull-out from osteoporotic bone, augmentation with calcium phosphate bone substitute material increases load to failure resistance.