[Comparison of multi-tract PCNL and single-tract ECIRS in semisupine-lithotomy position for staghorn renal calculi].

Objective: To compare the outcomes of multi-tract percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) and simultaneous combined single-tract percutaneous nephrolithotomy and flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy (ECIRS) as treatment for staghorn stones. Methods: The clinical data of patients with staghorn stones who were treated with multi-tract PCNL or single-tract ECIRS in Sun Yat-sen Memorial Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University from January 2015 to December 2019 were retrospectively analyzed. Two group of patients were placed in semisupine-lithotomy position (Galdakao-modified supine Valdivia position). We punctured into the renal calyces guided by ultrasonography. A F6 double J stent and a nephrostomy tube were routinely inserted in both groups. Kidney-ureter-bladder radiography (KUB) or computed tomography (CT) were done within 24 hours and 1 month after procedure to determine stone free rate (SFR). Stone free was defined as no residual stones or residual stones of <4 mm in diameter. The SFR, operating time, intraoperative and postoperative complications, and hospitalization time of the two groups were compared and analyzed. Results: A total of 135 patients were included in the study, 70 patients were female, 65 patients were male. The average age were 50.8 years. A total of 74 patients were managed by multi-tract PCNL, while 61 patients were treated by single-tract ECIRS. The mean stone diameter was (58.5±11.4) mm in the PCNL group and (57.7±11.6) mm in the ECIRS group (P=0.658). Neither the 24-hour SFR (81.1% vs 80.3%) nor one-month SFR (91.9% vs 90.2%) after procedure was significantly different between the groups (both P>0.05). The operating time was significantly longer in PCNL group compared with ECIRS group [130(100,171) vs 105(90,135) min, P=0.015]. The rate of Clavien-Dindo grade 2 or higher were significantly higher in the PCNL group than the ECIRS group (18.92% vs 1.64%, P<0.01). The PCNL group required longer hospitalization time than the ECIRS group [8 (7, 9) vs 6 (5, 8) d, P<0.01]. Conclusions: Both multi-tract PCNL and single-tract ECIRS treating staghorn stones in semisupine-lithotomy position are safe and effective. The two procedures have comparable SFR. However, the ECIRS group has lower rates of postoperative complications, shorter operating time and hospitalization time.