Comparison of Self-Expandable Acurate Neo-2 and Balloon-Expandable Myval Transcatheter Heart Valves at 4-Year Follow-Up.

BACKGROUND

Recently, Acurate neo2 (ACN2; Boston Scientific, US) and Sapien-3 series (Edwards Lifesciences, US) were compared in the IDE trial failing to demonstrate non-inferiority of ACN2. The Myval series (MyV), an alternative balloon-expandable device, demonstrated non-inferiority compared to Sapien-3 and Evolut (Medtronic, US) in the LANDMARK trial. However, no direct comparison exists between ACN2 and MyV.

AIMS: We aimed to compare mid-term clinical and hemodynamic outcomes of the ACN2 and MyV transcatheter heart valves.

METHODS

This multicenter retrospective analysis included patients implanted with ACN2 and MyV series devices. The primary objective was to assess 1-year mortality and stroke rates. Secondary outcomes included technical success, mortality, stroke, residual aortic regurgitation (AR), mean aortic gradients, and new permanent pacemaker implantation (PPI) rates up to 4 years. A matched comparison adjusting for clinical and anatomical characteristics was performed and echocardiograms were centrally analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 545 patients (ACN2: 144; MyV: 401) from nine institutions were included. Matched technical success rates were 87.6% and 94.4%, p = 0.180 (90.3% for ACN2 and 97% for MyV; p < 0.001 in unmatched). In-hospital matched PPI rates were 10.1% for ACN2 and 9% for MyV. At 4 years, matched residual ≥ moderate AR rates were similar (ACN2: 15.8% vs. MyV: 21.1%, p = 0.706), though ACN2 showed better mean aortic gradients (9.2 ± 4.2 vs. 13.1 ± 5.4, p = 0.001) and effective orifice area. Unmatched mortality + stroke rates were comparable but lower for ACN2 after matching (3.4% vs. 15.7%, p = 0.005). Importantly, cardiovascular mortality (3.4% for ACN2 and 5.6% for MyV, p = 0.720) and valve-related deaths were comparable.

CONCLUSION

ACN2 showed superior long-term hemodynamics and lower matched 4-year mortality and stroke rates, though cardiovascular mortality and valve-related deaths were comparable.