MedElevator Войти в исследования
← Поиск публикаций

DOI 10.1001/jamadermatol.2026.1697

Медицинская библиотека · JAMA dermatology · 2026

Development of a Core Outcome Domain Set for Facial Aging.

Dirr McKenzie A, Ahmed Areeba, Schlessinger Daniel I, Lazaro-Camp Vanessa, Smith Sabrina, Gullapalli Thanvi, Dragovic Doroteja, Chang Joycie, Zhang Elizabeth, Alam Murad, Facial Aging Core Outcome Domain Set Study Group, Anvery Noor, Christensen Rachel E, Ibrahim Sarah A, Kang Bianca Y, Wong Clarissa, Iyengar Sanjana, Yanes Arianna F, Cotseones Jill, Ashchyan Hovik J, Patel Payal M, Sheikh Umar A, Franklin Matthew J, Hanna Courtney C, Chiren Sarah G, Schmitt Jochen, Furlan Karina C, Alexiades Macrene, Alhusayen Raed, Alster Tina S, Beer Kenneth, Bertucci Vince, Bloom Jason D, Briceño César A, Bucay Vivian, Butterwick Kimberly J, Hugues Cartier, Casabona Gabriela, Connolly Karen L, Cotofana Sebastian, Council Martha Laurin, Cox Sue Ellen, Darmanescu Monica, De Boulle Koenraad, Desai Shraddha, Donofrio Lisa M, Dover Jeffrey S, Draelos Zoe, Eisen Daniel B, El-Domyati Moetaz, El-Garem Yehia, Fischer John, Fitzgerald Rebecca, Friedmann Daniel P, Galadari Hassan, Gladstone Hayes B, Goldman Mitchel P, Goodman Greg J, Green Jeremy B, Halachmi Shlomit, Hanke C William, Humphrey Shannon, Ibrahim Sherrif F, Jagdeo Jared, Jiang Shang I Brian, Karen Julie K, Kauvar Arielle, Kibbi Abdul-Ghani, Kim John V S, Kim Jenny, de Lacerda Davi, Lask Gary, Lopez Grace M, Lupo Mary P, Mariwalla Kavita, Matarasso Seth, Mekokishvili Lally, Narins Rhoda S, Ogilvie Patricia, Orringer Jeffrey S, Osaki Tammy H, Ozog David, Pacheco Theresa, Polder Kristel, Rossi Anthony M, Sadick Neil, Saedi Nazanin, Schlessinger Joel, Sharad Jaishree, Shenoy Manjunath M, Sinclair Rodney, Solish Nowell, Piansay-Soriano Miriam Emily, Sulyman Omotara, Szeimies Rolf-Markus, Tanzi Elizabeth L, Taub Amy Forman, Taylor Mark B, Thomas J Regan, Torezan Luis, Tosti Antonella, Touma Dany, Trindade de Almeida Ada Regina, Vedamurthy Maya, Viana Giovanni, Waldman Abigail, Weinkle Susan H, Weiss Robert, Poon Emily, Maher Ian A, Cartee Todd V, Sobanko Joseph F, Kirkham Jamie J

СтатьяОбзорПеревод в очереди

Аннотация

IMPORTANCE

Currently, there are no standardized outcome domains or measures in clinical trials for facial aging. Heterogeneity in outcome domains and measurement instruments across clinical trials creates difficulty in directly comparing interventions, determining superior therapies, and developing high-quality meta-analyses.

OBJECTIVE

To develop a core outcome set (COS) of essential domains to be reported in clinical trials evaluating the efficacy of interventions for facial aging.

EVIDENCE REVIEW: PubMed/Medline, Embase, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and CINAHL were searched from September 2005 to September 2015. An updated search of the same databases was performed from September 2015 to February 2026. Studies were included if (1) they were randomized clinical trial or controlled clinical trial in design, (2) they assessed the efficacy or safety of an intervention for facial aging, (3) they were published in English, and (4) they involved human participants. Complementary sources, including patient interviews, were used to capture further relevant outcomes. Two rounds of Delphi surveys, followed by consensus meetings, were used to identify outcome domains considered most important by both patient and physician stakeholders.

FINDINGS: The final COS consists of 6 outcome domains: (1) overall convenience of treatment; (2) time to return to normal work and social activity; (3) overall assessment of focused area of treatment (at the point in time when treatment is expected to provide peak benefit); (4) duration of treatment effect; (5) severity of persistent local or systemic adverse events, including pigmentary change, skin texture change, delayed healing, scarring, and serious adverse events; and (6) patient satisfaction with treatment.

CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: The 6 outcome domains identified through a Delphi consensus are recommended for reporting in future facial aging trials to ensure that outcomes that matter most to patients and clinicians are measured and that results are comparable across interventions.

Для цитирования: Dirr McKenzie A, Ahmed Areeba, Schlessinger Daniel I, Lazaro-Camp Vanessa, Smith Sabrina, Gullapalli Thanvi, Dragovic Doroteja, Chang Joycie, Zhang Elizabeth, Alam Murad, Facial Aging Core Outcome Domain Set Study Group, Anvery Noor, Christensen Rachel E, Ibrahim Sarah A, Kang Bianca Y, Wong Clarissa, Iyengar Sanjana, Yanes Arianna F, Cotseones Jill, Ashchyan Hovik J, Patel Payal M, Sheikh Umar A, Franklin Matthew J, Hanna Courtney C, Chiren Sarah G, Schmitt Jochen, Furlan Karina C, Alexiades Macrene, Alhusayen Raed, Alster Tina S, Beer Kenneth, Bertucci Vince, Bloom Jason D, Briceño César A, Bucay Vivian, Butterwick Kimberly J, Hugues Cartier, Casabona Gabriela, Connolly Karen L, Cotofana Sebastian, Council Martha Laurin, Cox Sue Ellen, Darmanescu Monica, De Boulle Koenraad, Desai Shraddha, Donofrio Lisa M, Dover Jeffrey S, Draelos Zoe, Eisen Daniel B, El-Domyati Moetaz, El-Garem Yehia, Fischer John, Fitzgerald Rebecca, Friedmann Daniel P, Galadari Hassan, Gladstone Hayes B, Goldman Mitchel P, Goodman Greg J, Green Jeremy B, Halachmi Shlomit, Hanke C William, Humphrey Shannon, Ibrahim Sherrif F, Jagdeo Jared, Jiang Shang I Brian, Karen Julie K, Kauvar Arielle, Kibbi Abdul-Ghani, Kim John V S, Kim Jenny, de Lacerda Davi, Lask Gary, Lopez Grace M, Lupo Mary P, Mariwalla Kavita, Matarasso Seth, Mekokishvili Lally, Narins Rhoda S, Ogilvie Patricia, Orringer Jeffrey S, Osaki Tammy H, Ozog David, Pacheco Theresa, Polder Kristel, Rossi Anthony M, Sadick Neil, Saedi Nazanin, Schlessinger Joel, Sharad Jaishree, Shenoy Manjunath M, Sinclair Rodney, Solish Nowell, Piansay-Soriano Miriam Emily, Sulyman Omotara, Szeimies Rolf-Markus, Tanzi Elizabeth L, Taub Amy Forman, Taylor Mark B, Thomas J Regan, Torezan Luis, Tosti Antonella, Touma Dany, Trindade de Almeida Ada Regina, Vedamurthy Maya, Viana Giovanni, Waldman Abigail, Weinkle Susan H, Weiss Robert, Poon Emily, Maher Ian A, Cartee Todd V, Sobanko Joseph F, Kirkham Jamie J. Development of a Core Outcome Domain Set for Facial Aging.. JAMA dermatology. 2026. DOI: 10.1001/jamadermatol.2026.1697.

Предметные рубрики MeSH

Подготовка и перевод публикации
Обработка статьи · этапы, ошибки и управление
Загрузка состояния…

История · было → стало

Состояние обновляется каждые 5 секунд, пока блок открыт. Процент показывается только там, где известен объём работы. Пауза останавливает продолжение этапа; текущий запрос к источнику может завершиться.

Тип публикации указан по данным источника. Уровень доказательности автоматически не присваивается.