Hearing outcomes in stapes surgery: a comparison of fat, fascia, and vein tissue seals.

OBJECTIVE: To compare short- and long-term hearing results following stapedectomy using 3 different oval window grafting materials with the same stapes prosthesis.

STUDY DESIGN: Database review.

SETTING: Tertiary referral private practice.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Subjects were ears that underwent stapedectomy for otosclerosis, with placement of fat, fascia, or vein as an oval window seal and reconstruction with a titanium bucket handle prosthesis. A total of 365 procedures met these inclusion criteria: 98 fat grafts, 135 fascia grafts, and 132 vein grafts. Outcome measures included short-term (<1 year) and long-term follow-up air-bone gap. We compared the preoperative and postoperative amount of change in air-bone gap and preoperative and postoperative amount of change in the high-frequency bone conduction average.

RESULTS: Overall median times to short-term and long-term follow-ups were 2.2 months and 36.1 months, respectively. There were no statistically significant differences between the 3 tissue seal groups in the amount of change in air-bone gap. There was no significant difference in amount of change in high-frequency bone conduction (representing sensorineural hearing level) between the 3 tissue seal groups. Most patients in all 3 groups had an air-bone gap at long-term follow-up of ≤ 10 dB (fat, 79.5%; fascia, 78.8%; and vein, 75.6%), with 90.3% of all patients at ≤ 20 dB.

CONCLUSIONS: In both the short-term postoperative period and long-term follow-up, there were no significant differences in hearing results among 3 types of tissue seals of the oval window in stapes surgery. Fat, fascia, and vein grafts all provide satisfactory hearing outcomes in stapedectomy.