Comorbidity for borderline and schizotypal personality disorders. A study of alcoholic women.

Twenty-six women alcoholics who fulfilled the criteria for a pure borderline personality disorder (BPD) were compared with 16 women alcoholics who also fulfilled the criteria of a schizotypal personality disorder (called mixed borderline disorder, MBD) based on personal interviews including SADS, SIB, Childhood Environment Scale (CES), and the Premorbid Adjustment Scale (PAC). The MBD women had fewer alcoholic relatives, poorer relationships with parents and siblings, a more deviant score on CES and PAC, a higher incidence of nervous children, and a poorer social network. They also reported more losses and a greater frequency of depressive symptoms during childhood and adolescence, earlier contact with psychiatry, and more frequent hospitalizations. They had a higher frequency of a nonalcoholic axis I disorder (mainly depressive and anxiety disorders), as well as a greater frequency of a paranoid personality disorder. The results show that the MBD women were more psychopathologically disturbed and support a possible link between MBD and affective disorders. The findings also indicate that MBD may be a clinical entity that should be differentiated from the pure BPD group both in clinical work and forthcoming research.