Approaches to transcatheter aortic valve replacement failure: is more focus on prevention required?

INTRODUCTION

Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR) has transformed the management of severe aortic stenosis across all surgical risk strata. As its use expands to younger, lower-risk patients, the durability of transcatheter heart valves and the clinical consequences of prosthetic failure have become critically important. Despite a growing literature on reintervention strategies, systematic prevention of TAVR failure remains comparatively underemphasized.

AREAS COVERED: We searched PubMed and the Cochrane Library (2000-2026, English language) for studies on TAVR failure and its prevention. This review examines the mechanisms of TAVR failure, including structural valve deterioration, paravalvular leak, prosthesis-patient mismatch, subclinical leaflet thrombosis, valve endocarditis, and device migration; appraises current management, including valve-in-valve TAVR, redo surgical aortic valve replacement, and medical therapy; and reviews prevention strategies spanning patient selection, procedural optimization, antithrombotic management, structural surveillance, coronary access preservation, and lifetime planning.

EXPERT OPINION: The evidence base has focused disproportionately on reintervention rather than prevention. Greater emphasis on structured lifetime management planning at index TAVR, individualized antithrombotic strategies, and evidence-based surveillance is needed. Several proposed measures, however, including routine anticoagulation for subclinical leaflet thrombosis and routine CT or artificial-intelligence-based surveillance, are not yet supported by outcome data and require prospective validation.