A randomized clinical trial of two methods of fascia lata suspension in congenital ptosis.

PURPOSE: To compare the results of 2 methods of upper eyelid sling placement with autogenous fascia lata in the treatment of congenital ptosis.

METHODS

In a randomized clinical trial, patients with congenital upper eyelid ptosis and poor levator function (<4 mm) were randomly assigned to either of 2 methods of upper eyelid sling placement: group A, bitriangular fascia sling (modified Crawford method), and group B, monotriangular fascia sling (modified Fox method).

RESULTS

This study included 30 upper eyelids (15 eyelids in each surgical group) of 19 patients (8 unilateral and 11 bilateral cases) with congenital ptosis. Mean increase in eyelid fissure height was 2.7 +/- 2.3 mm in group A and 3.4 +/- 2.2 mm in group B. Change in eyelid fissure in both groups was significant (p < 0.001, paired t test) but the intergroup difference was not (p = 0.4, independent sample t test). Early complications such as corneal epithelial defects and entropion and late complications such as undercorrection were comparable in the 2 groups. No patient experienced recurrent ptosis requiring reoperation in either group.

CONCLUSIONS

The monotriangular method of upper eyelid fascia sling placement can be used instead of the more popular bitriangular method. Advantages include less need for fascial tissue, less periocular scar formation, and a shorter period of anesthesia.