Clear cell changes in mucinous tubular and spindle cell carcinoma: cytoplasmic pallor/clearing within tubules, vacuoles or hybrid conventional clear cell carcinoma of kidney?

Mucinous tubular and spindle cell carcinoma (MTSCC) is a rare and recently recognized subtype of renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Apart from the classic morphology comprising conventional three components, there exist a large number of non-classic morphological variants of MTSCC, which make it necessity to differentiate from other RCC. Herein, we report two non-classic morphological variants of MTSCC. Case 1, a 85 years old man, showed numerous vacuoles among inherent components and cytoplasmic pallor/clearing within tubules mimicking conventional clear cell RCC with a 8.5 years follow-up, while Case 2 indicated a "mucin-poor" MTSCC associated with simultaneous conventional clear cell RCC at her age of 73 years. Until now Case 1 carries the longest disease-free survival reported in literature since MTSCC was defined and ranks the oldest since reported in literature, while Case 2 is the first report of "mucin-poor" MTSCC associated with simultaneous conventional clear cell RCC. Now, since no biomarkers or imagining tools but pathological examination can confirm the diagnosis of MTSCC, the management is always following the guideline of RCC in clinical practice. Generally, most reports consider it as a good prognosis disease, but sarcomatoid variant, even classic subtype can progress rapidly to life-threatening disease.