False-positive cases in multiple sleep latency test by accumulated sleep debt.

PURPOSE: Multiple sleep latency test (MSLT) is performed as objective assessment of sleepiness, on the following day after polysomnography (PSG). In most clinics, patients are required to stay for 2 days. However, if patients have chronic sleep debt before the examination, even if they get adequate nocturnal sleep during the initial PSG, their sleep debt would not be fully resolved, affecting MSLT results. This may lead to improper administration of psycho-stimulant medication. To clarify the sleep debt for the patients who showed short sleep latencies, we compared the mean sleep latencies of MSLTs.

METHODS

Twelve hypersomnolent males, who underwent MSLTs (1st MSLT with 1 night and 2nd MSLT with more than 3 nights), were enrolled. We selected these cases based on the longer total sleep time on PSG night compared to the mean total sleep time on pre-examination sleep logs and shortened sleep latencies on PSG. To evaluate the effect of the sleep debt for the patients who showed short sleep latencies, we extended their hospitalization or re-hospitalized them.

RESULTS

The mean sleep latency of 1st MSLT was 5.8 minutes and that of 2nd was 13.9 minutes (P < .001). Among these 12 cases, 5 cases altered from short to normal sleep latencies at the 2nd MSLT. These 5 cases were prevented from over-diagnoses by the extension of evaluations.

CONCLUSIONS

The sleep debt may produce false-positive results when patients are examined by standard PSG and MSLT. Accumulation of sleep debt will cause shortened sleep latencies in the following nights. Patients should be advised to extend their hospitalization before PSG and MSLT to reduce the chronic sleep debt for accurate diagnosis of hypersomnia.