Mild HIV-specific selective forces overlaying natural CD4+ T cell dynamics explain the clonality and decay dynamics of HIV reservoir cells.

To determine whether HIV persistence arises from the natural dynamics of memory (m)CD4+ T cells, we compare clonal dynamics of HIV proviruses and mCD4+ T cells from the same people living with HIV (PWH) on antiretroviral therapy and from matched HIV-seronegative people (N = 51). HIV proviruses are more clonal than mCD4+ T cells but similarly clonal to antigen-specific cells. Increasing reservoir clonality over time and differential decay of intact and defective proviruses are not explained by mCD4+ T cell kinetics alone. We develop and validate a stochastic model trained on 10 quantitative data metrics, which shows that negative selection against HIV-infected cells is necessary to explain all metrics. We estimate the strength of negative selection, finding that death of cells harboring intact and defective proviruses is infrequently (∼6% and ∼2% on average) due to HIV-specific factors. Thus, our data indicate that HIV persistence is mostly, but not entirely, driven by natural mCD4+ kinetics.