Pragmatic comparison of beta2-agonist side effects within the Worldwide Atosiban versus Beta Agonists study.

OBJECTIVE

While beta2-agonists for the acute treatment of preterm labour unequivocally reduce the odds of delivery within 48 h and 7 days, they have been associated with substantial maternal and fetal side effects. We aimed to compare side effect profiles of beta2-agonist tocolytics.

STUDY

DESIGN

Pragmatic comparison of ritodrine, salbutamol and terbutaline from re-analysis of data obtained within three comparator arms of three simultaneous comparable randomised controlled trials of beta2-agonists against atosiban in 742 women in preterm labour. The prevalence of categoric side effects between treatment groups was analysed using a chi2 test. The differences in continuous variables between treatment groups were analysed in analyses of covariance.

RESULTS

The prevalence of categoric side effects was similar with the three drugs, with the exception of the subjective symptom of palpitations (ritodrine 24.0%, terbutaline 9.3% and salbutamol 12.3%, P=0.003). There were also some differences in maternal diastolic blood pressure (P<0.001) and serum glucose levels (P<0.001), although these were small (<3 mmHg and < or =2.8 mmol/L, respectively) and clinically unimportant.

CONCLUSION

Side effects were common with all three drugs. Thus, choosing one beta2-agonist over the other to minimise side effects has little rationale, especially now that safer tocolytics are available.