False positive findings associated with adenoviral vector-based vaccine underscore the regulatory necessity to eliminate abnormal toxicity test.

Accumulating evidence has shown that the abnormal toxicity test (ATT) is not suitable as a quality control batch release test for biologics and vaccines. The purpose of the current study was to explore the optimal ATT experimental design for an adenoviral vector-based vaccine product to avoid false positive results following the standard test conditions stipulated in the Pharmacopoeias. ATT were conducted in both mice and guinea pigs based on methods in Pharmacopeias, with modifications to assess effects of dose volume and amount of virus particles (VPs). The results showed intraperitoneal (IP) dosing at human relevant dose and volume (i.e., VPs), as required by pharmacopeia study design, resulted in false positive findings not associated with extraneous contaminants of a product. Considering many gene therapy products use adeno associated virus as the platform for transgene delivery, data from this study are highly relevant in providing convincing evidence to show the ATT is inappropriate as batch release test for biologics, vaccine and gene therapy products. In conclusion, ATT, which requires unnecessary animal usage and competes for resources which otherwise can be spent on innovative medicine research, should be deleted permanently as batch release test by regulatory authorities around the world.