Is the perception of brightness different in poor readers?

The transient system deficit hypothesis (TSDH) of specific reading disability [Percept. Psychophys. 40 (1986) 440] remains contentious. As part of a study examining multiple measures of transient and sustained system function, heterochromatic flicker matching (HFM) and brightness matching (HBM) were assessed in 30 poor readers (9.11+/-0.68 years) and 30 age, grade and sex matched controls (9.24+/-0.73 years). HBM and HFM are known to reflect the processing of brightness and luminance information and have been related to the function of magnocellular and parvocellular visual sub-systems. Flicker and brightness matches were determined for blue, green, yellow and red stimuli on Macintosh colour displays using 2AFC and double interleaved random staircases. A ratio of the luminances for brightness and flicker matches represented performance. A significant difference between controls and poor readers in performance for red and blue stimuli was found indicating different visual function in poor readers. While not providing direct support for the transient system deficit hypothesis, this effect implies a mismatch between those achromatic systems that subserve HFM and those more complex mechanisms involved in HBM. The most important aspect of this finding is that poor readers and normal controls could be differentiated on the basis of a paradigm known to be contingent upon magnocellular and parvocellular functioning.