Clean Intermittent Catheterisation via a Mitrofanoff Is Superior to Long Term Suprapubic Catheters for Bladder Drainage.

AIM: Some children require long-term drainage of the bladder but do not tolerate clean intermittent catheterisation (CIC) urethrally. We aimed to compare long term suprapubic catheter (SPC) drainage vs Mitrofanoff conduit (allowing CIC) by comparing the survival of the drainage methods and rates of urinary tract infection (UTI).

METHOD: Retrospective review of a single surgeon's experience (2007-2023). Data collection included diagnosis, age at procedures, date of surgery, date of most recent follow-up and date and reason for unplanned surgery. For SPCs, initial insertion of SPC and then conversion to a Foley catheter under GA was taken as normal (event free survival) and only further operations were counted as complication events. For Mitrofanoffs, any subsequent operation was counted as a complication. Data were given as a number (%) or median (interquartile range) as appropriate. Data analysed by Fisher exact and Mann-Whitney U-test. Kaplan Meier (KM) survival of drainage routes was compared, P < 0.05 taken as significant.

RESULTS

There were 45 patients (n = 86 SPC episodes) compared to 108 patients (n = 110 Mitrofanoff procedures). Data were available in 73 SPC episodes and 109 Mitrofanoff episodes, including 3 redo procedures (one from another centre). There was no difference in gender (SPC group, 67 % male vs. Mitrofanoff group, 77 %; N.S.). There was no difference in age at procedure [7.5 (2.9-11.5) years vs 8.3 (5.9-11.4) years respectively; N.S.) KM comparison showed that Mitrofanoff have a better event-free survival than SPC (91 % vs 52 % at 1 year; 80 % vs. 13 % at 5 years; P < 0.0001). Paired data showed a significant (86 %) reduction in rate of UTI with conversion from SPC to Mitrofanoff drainage in 15 patients; SPC: 0.13 (0-0.46) UTIs/month vs subsequent Mitrofanoff: 0.02 (0-0.08) UTI/month, P = 0.04).

CONCLUSION

SPCs had a much higher rate of unplanned surgery than Mitrofanoffs, creating a considerable unplanned burden of care for families and clinical staff. For long-term bladder drainage CIC via a Mitrofanoff conduit should be considered in preference to SPC where urethral CIC is not possible.