Intolerance of uncertainty and depression in children and adolescents: Systematic review and meta-analysis.

BACKGROUND

Intolerance of uncertainty (IU) is a development and maintenance factor for depression and anxiety. Previous reviews found that it associated with anxiety in children and adolescents. However, there was insufficient evidence at the time to review its association with depression in this population.

METHOD: 20 studies investigating the relationship between IU and depression in children and adolescents were identified. Random effects meta-analysis was used to aggregate cross-sectional associations, with age, gender, and measure as moderators. A narrative review of longitudinal findings from relevant studies (K = 6) was also conducted.

RESULTS

Meta-analysis of cross-sectional associations found an overall effect size of r = 0.47. There was limited evidence that age or gender moderated the effect, however there was a significant moderating effect of measure. Namely, when including studies using 'child-friendly' measures (i.e., developed and normed with children as opposed to adults), the effect size was r = 0.37. Another analysis revealed that the inhibitory IU subscale was more strongly associated with depression than prospective IU. Longitudinal findings suggested that the association between IU and depression persists over time.

LIMITATIONS: Studies were limited to those published in English and including general population samples (e.g., typically developing, without significant medical needs).

CONCLUSIONS

There is a medium-strong association between IU and depression symptoms in children and adolescents. However, it may be overestimated by the use of IU measures that are not child-friendly. Future research can further extend the evidence-base through careful measure selection, as well as longitudinal and experimental designs.